Please Forgive Me - (Dean Winchester x Reader)

Goodbye

You see the pain etched on his face. You glance over to Sam who’s tied to the opposite pillar you are, your eyes fall back to Dean. He pulls against his restraints, as the demon taught him.

“Come, come Mr Winchester. I haven’t got all day. Choose” he points the gun in the direction of you and Sam

“Choose who dies, Y/n or Sam. Y/n? The only woman you claimed to have ever truly loved. Or Sam? Your brother, the man you’ve died and risked your life for over and over again” he spins on his heel practically dancing with glee.

“Because make no mistake, at least one of them is going to die tonight. If you refuse to pick one, I’ll kill them both” you feel a tear fall from your eye. You knew one day it would come to this.

“Dean, pick me! It’ll be fine, just pick me!” Sam shouts across the room. Dean ignores him and stares at you.

You see the tears fall from his eyes, you knew he wasn’t going to let Sam die. You let out a silent sob, closing your eyes lightly, more tears streaming down your cheeks. You open them again, nodding at the love of your life, letting him know it was ok.

You both ignored Sam’s plea’s, Dean drops his head letting his own tears fall.

“I’m sorry…” he sobs, bloodshot eyes meeting yours again. The demon walks towards you, stopping when he reaches your side, raising his gun to your head. “Forgive me…” he whimpers turning his head away.

“I love you" you whisper closing your eyes, weeping.

You never even heard the gun shot.