creepypasta x male reader boyfriend sanarios

when he try's to get you back

Slenderman.

Y/n groaned in frustration as he heard a knock on the door making him pause his movie as he got up and walked over then opened the door to see Slenderman standing there in his human form "what do you want?" Y/n sighed leaning on the doorframe "I want you back, please I'm so sorry for everything I hate seeing you with that other guy" Slender begged "then don't look" Y/n said making Slender sigh softly as he looked a little rough and sounded tired "please, I'll do anything" Slender said making Y/n sigh "I'll think about it, go get some rest" Y/n said closing the door.

Jeff.

Y/n woke up to a soft tapping on his window making him whine softly as he got up then saw Jeff at the window making him sigh as he opened it "what?" he mumbled rubbing his e/c eyes half asleep but Jeff hugged Y/n his arms around his waist and nuzzled into his neck "Jeff" Y/n sighed "I want you back please" Jeff whispered his shoulders shaking a bit as Y/n felt tears on his shoulder, he wrapped his arms around Jeffs shoulders and tangled his fingers into the back of his long messy black hair "Jeff you hurt me. I don't know if I can ever trust you again" Y/n said softly feeling Jeff hold him tighter "I'm... I'm sorry. It'll never happen again I promise I'll do anything for you, I'll even give up killing if you asked" Jeff sniffled Y/n's touch comforting him "I'll think about it, go home take a shower and get some sleep, we'll talk tomorrow" Y/n said softly "promise?" Jeff asked moving back to look at Y/n "yes, go home" Y/n said softly making Jeff nod "I really am sorry" he said looking over from the window "I know. go on get out of here" Y/n said with a soft smile as Jeff crawled out then jumped off the roof.

Ticci Toby.

Y/n walked out the pharmacy with Michael holding his hand, Toby walked over wearing his hoodie but without his mask or hatchets and a plaster over his chewed cheek "Y/n" he said quietly making Y/n and Michael look over "c-an we talk?" Toby asked looking tired and like he had been crying "I'll go get us some snacks" Michael said kissing Y/n's cheek before he walked off "you ok?" Y/n asked "n-no" Toby sighed scratching at his arm "you been taking shit Hel gives you?" Y/n sighed as Toby nodded "I-I don't know w-hat else to do. I n-need you" Toby said sniffling as a few tears falling from his chocolate brown eyes "I'll d-do anything y-ou want p-please" Toby begged making Y/n sigh softly "come over in the morning we'll talk about it" Y/n said as Michael walked over "th-thanks" Toby said as Y/n nodded then walked off with Michael.

Ben drowned.

Y/n was laying on his sofa listening to music and scrolling on his phone before the tv turned to static and Ben flopped out half a joint in his mouth making Y/n sigh as he smelled like a mini bar "I wanted to apologise, properly" Ben said sitting up "Ben" Y/n sighed sitting up "I'm sorry I'm really sorry" Ben said a few blood like tears running down his cheeks "no 'I'll do anything for you' or anything like that?" Y/n asked making Ben look down and scratch his arm "I don't expect you to take me back. I just wanted to apologise, there's not much else I can do" Ben said looking up at Y/n "I know, but that doesn't mean it doesn't hurt. go sober up we'll talk tomorrow" Y/n said getting up "thanks, for hearing me out" Ben said then crawled back into the tv as Y/n walked upstairs to get ready for work. 

Masky.

Masky tapped on Y/n's window then waited for a few seconds before it opened and Y/n let him crawl in "its late, why are you here?" Y/n asked then froze as Masky hugged him "Tim" Y/n said softly wrapping his arms around him "I'm sorry, It'll never happen again I promise I've been so messed up since you left me" Masky whimpered crying softly "I need you please" Masky cried holding onto Y/n's top "its ok, calm down" Y/n said softly as he gently took Masky's mask off and wiped his tears away "take your pills and get some rest, you can stay in the guest bedroom for tonight we'll talk in the morning" Y/n said softly making Masky nod as he followed Y/n to the guest room.