Free to Be You and Me - A Supernatural Lucifer x Reader Story

Chapter 3 - A New Friendship

You walked into your room and found Lucifer sitting on your bed. You closed the door and waltzed over.

"Well, like Star Wars do we? I never would have guessed." he said as he glanced at all your posters.

"Yeah, I also like the Avengers, dragons, and other things they put on posters. But, as you said, you never would have guessed," You replied as you sat down next to him on the bed.

Lucifer started to look confused, "Wait, are you actually just... talking to me?"

"Yup."

"Hmm."

You all sat there for a few minutes.

"So, how long have you know Sam and Dean?" he asked.

"Personally, for a few months. But I've watched them for forever now."

Lucifer was definitely confused now.

"Oh yeah, I forgot, they never told you."

So you explained how you came from a different universe and explained to him what had happened.

"Damn. That must've been a big shock to you," Lucifer said.

You shrugged and told him, "It wasn't that bad. I really didn't have that much to hold onto in the other universe. Crappy job, not much family. I mean, I was living an alright life, but I like it much better here."

Lucifer nodded.

"So if you watched them... that means you have watched me right? Right? Who am I played by? Is he cool? " he asked.

"Yeah I've watched you. You're played by Mark Pellegrino, cool guy, from what I have seen at least."

Lucifer chuckled, "So fake me is named after some drink?"

You laughed, "Yeah, apparently."

He was smiling. You were smiling. You liked this. Why Sam, Dean or Cass couldn't handle him, you had no idea.

You were staring at each other, smiles fading. You just kind of looked into each other's eyes for a moment.

Lucifer started to say something, but held back.

You shook your head and asked him, "So, have you seen Star Wars?"

After several hours of binging the Star Wars prequels on your computer (His vessel had already seen the trilogy) and several trips for snacks. It was around six o'clock.

Your stomach growled as you laid on the bed. Lucifer looked over at you.

He sighed, "Are you hungry, AGAIN?"

You nodded.

"How can a human eat so much!?"

You laughed, "See I only eat a little at a time. I like snacking more than eating some big meal all at once."

"Yeah, yeah."

You hopped off the bed at started walking to the kitchen, Lucifer trailing after you.

Dean saw you, and chuckled, "So, he gotten on your nerves yet? Ready to hear out our plan?"

"Nope," you told him as you got out the popcorn and put it in the microwave.

"Nope?"

"Nope."

Dean stared at you, he looked a little uneasy, "What the hell do you mean by nope?"

"Nope means nope. Everything is going very smooth and, " you patted Lucifer on his head, "he's been a good boy."

Lucifer mimicked a dog and growled and barked at Dean.

Dean shook his head and left the kitchen.

You started laughing, Lucifer was too.

BEEP BEEP BEEP went the microwave.

"HoLy SHiT!" you exclaimed as you nearly jumped out of your skin.

Lucifer doubled over in laughter.

You frowned, "That wasn't funny!"

He was still laughing.

"Alright fine, maybe a little funny."

You were back in your room, sitting on your bed. You and Lucifer had already polished off the bowl of popcorn.

Lucifer started chuckling.

"What?" you asked.

"Afterwards, you looked like you had just seen a ghost! Ha!"

You frowned and punched him in the shoulder, "Shut it!"

He grabbed your hand that had punched his shoulder, "Make me."

So you two started wrestling. You had him on his back trying to get him when he suddenly flipped you on the bed and pinned your hands down. He pinned your legs against the bed with his.

"Surrender now and I may give you mercy," he stated.

"Never!" you exclaimed as you started thrashing about.

After a few minutes of that, he still had you pinned down.

You grunted, "Fine, you win! Now get off you big oaf."

He didn't get off, he just kind of drifted off, looking into your eyes.

"Lucifer wha-"

He got off and just sat on the bed.

"What was that? Extra punishment or something?"

Lucifer shook his head and kind of looked down at the floor.

You sat back up on the bed and scooted closer to him, "Lucifer, what's wrong?"

"Nothing!" he kind of half cried, half yelled.

He shook his head and got up, "I'm going to bed."

"Alright, I'll get your sleeping bag."

You set out his sleeping bag, blankets and pillows.

He slipped into the sleeping bag and fell asleep.

You kind of just sat on your bed for a few minutes, staring at him, asking yourself,

What the hell did I do? What is wrong with him? Dammit.

You turned out the lights and tucked yourself into bed.

It was going to be tough falling asleep.