Cherry On Top (Cheryl and Toni)

Chapter one - The beginning

It was Toni's first night at Thistlehouse and she couldn't believe she finally moved in with her girlfriend. "Welcome home babe." The redhead told her a few minutes ago when she arrived before heading upstairs to take a shower. Cheryl was in their room unpacking the brunette backpack when she found something that caught her attention; lube. She smirked at the taught of her and Toni having sex for the first time. Cheryl was a virgin and she wanted to go slow with Toni but she also wanted all of Toni so bad. So bad that she slid her hand down her pantie unconsciously and started to play with herself. Toni, who had finished taking her shower stood in the doorway spying on her girlfriend who was fingering herself. "Need help ?" The brunette asked making her way into the room. "Toni." The redhead said, instantly removing her hand from her genitals. "I thought you were in the shower." She said, her cheek turning as red as her hair.

Toni noticed the bottle of lube still in Cheryl's hand. "You found my lube, as I notice." She said with a raised eyebrow. "It's not like you think Cheryl. I didn't buy this for you." Toni also added. Cheryl looked at her girlfriend furiously. "Then for who did you buy it ?" She yelled. "For me! And thank god you didn't found my vibrator." Toni said, a smirk spreading across her face. Cheryl's mouth went dry while her panties went wet. "You- you have a vibrator ?" Cheryl quietly asked her girl, fearing that Nana Rose would hear them even tho she was half deaf and downstairs. Toni smiled at her girlfriend. "Doesn't it, you know, hurt ?" Cheryl added. Toni looked up and down at her girlfriend. "Cheryl." She said " Are you... A virgin ?" Cheryl blushed at the truth. "For the record, I did see a penis in my life. I even touched it." The tall girl said, trying to defend herself. "I had one in between my legs." Toni said not really thinking. Cheryl looked at her. "You... You had sex before ?" She asked.

Toni looked at her girlfriend. "Yes. And I wish my first time would've been with you, Cheryl. I really do, but it happened and besides Sweet Pea and I were so young." She answered. "YOU LOST YOUR VIRGINITY TO SWEET PEA !" Cheryl yelled so hard that even Jughead, who was in the other end of the Southside could've heard her. Toni stopped breathing as she realized the mistake that she made. "Look, Cheryl, as long as I remember, I didn't know you when I was 13 and as I recall not even 3 months ago you wanted my head on a stick." The brunette said giving her girl some attitude. "AND YOU WERE 13! What the heck Toni !" Cheryl said not even trying to understand her girl. "Cheryl, my mom died during labor, my dad has been an alcoholic all his life and I'm an only child. I had a pretty rough childhood and Sweet Pea was the only one around for me. We kissed and then one thing followed another and before I knew, we were having sex." She said reaching out to her girlfriend who was still trying her best to ignore her. "It was this one time and it didn't mean anything to the both of us Cheryl. The only person I want to have sex with, is you." Toni said, her girlfriend's hand in hers.

It didn't take very long for Cheryl to push Toni on the bed and start to kiss her everywhere. Toni flipped them around, her now on top and looked in her girlfriend's eyes who were full in lust. "I think the fuck not Miss Bombshell. You might be the HBIC of the school but here in our bedroom I am the boss." She said, pinning the redhead's arms above her head. Cheryl pushed her breast up, making them touched with Toni's. They both stopped breathing for a second before Toni whipped Cheryl's shirt off of her, leaving her in a hot lacy red bra. The brunette smiled at this sight before she put a wet kiss on the area in between both boobs, making her way up to Cheryl's mouth, her tongue never leaving the redhead's skin. Cheryl let a moan escape into Toni's mouth, which made the brunette wet instantly, as if she wasn't already. She then reached behind Cheryl's back and unclipped her bra, exposing her breast. She ran her hand over them, shook at how hard they already were. "Toni..." Cheryl said directing the brunette attention to her eyes. "I want you, to take them in your mouth..." The tall girl said, gasping for air. Toni pinched her girlfriend's pink nipple between her thumb and index making Cheryl moan. "How about you beg for it ?" Toni said her tongue millimeters away from Cheryl's right nip.  "Please baby. Toni, fuck me with your fingers. I want you to make me cum. To make me regret hating you in the past."

Toni's hot breath on her boob made Cheryl shiver which resulted in her grinding against the short girl's leg. "Somebody's needy." Toni joked before giving her girlfriend what she has been begging for, starting by each one of her breast giving them both the same amount of love. Then she nibbled on Cheryl's neck before making her way down to her bellybutton leaving her tongue on Cheryl's body. By the time Toni removed Cheryl's undies, the redhead was already dripping wet. "Looks like we won't be needing the lube after all." Toni said, teasing the taller girl who was almost already jerking herself. Toni ran a finger along Cheryl's slit dragging all the wetness with her finger that she then proceeded to lick. "Fuck... You taste so sweet." She whispered into Cheryl's ear before getting back down and making circular motions around the redhead clit. Toni knew that Cheryl wouldn't last long so she plunged one finger inside her girlfriend's tight pussy. "Omg Cher, you are so tight." The brunette said pushing her finger in and out of Cheryl who was currently in heaven and unable to speak. A smile spread across Toni's face as she added a second finger in her girlfriend's hole. She knew that 2 fingers were all Cheryl could handle for now, that a 3rd finger would just hurt her, so she started to eat her girlfriend out as an extra. That being done, Cheryl almost came immediately, the pleasure was just too much to handle. As she was recovering from her first orgasm ever, she ran her hand on her forehead, pushing the streak of red hair that fell on her face away. "Damn..." Cheryl said a few minutes later, now being able to close her legs. The brunette smiled, proud of what she had done to the gorgeous girl laying besides her. "Toni... I think you're gonna need to help me to get to the bath... I don't think I'll be able to walk." Cheryl said, getting embarrassed by how weak Toni made her. The brunette helped her get to the bath and slid right behind her. She washed each and every single inches of her body and kissed her shoulder once she rinsed the soap away.

Cheryl was laying in bed in a t-shirt and panties, waiting for her girlfriend to get into her own pyjama and join her. Toni made her way into the bed and Cheryl laid her head on her chest listening to her heartbeat. "I love you Antoinette Topaz." Cheryl said. Toni was surprised by the word that escaped her girlfriend's mouth. Cheryl looked up at Toni, tears in her eyes. "I love you" she mouthed. "I love you too Cheryl Marjorie Blossom..." the brunette said running her fingers in Cheryl's long hair. Cheryl's heart skipped a beat at the sound of these words before a smile spread across her face. She finally found peace.