Smosh Preferences & Imagines

IMAGINE* Silver Lining (Shayne)

{Imagine watching a scary movie with Shayne and you have to comfort him}

In most couples, when you watch a scary movie, the boyfriend will take use it as an opportunity to hold the girl close to "protect" her. This was not the case when you were dating Shayne Robert Topp. You had been wanting to watch Stay Alive ever since your friend (f/n) told you about it. You loved the idea of "die in the game, die in real life". You had only been dating Shayne for a few weeks and knew he didn't love horror but didn't think he hated it. 

You had reached the end of the movie and he had both hands covering the sides of his face, with wide, sad eyes and furrowed eyebrows. Was he scared? He's such a tough guy. You were so enveloped by the movie that you didn't realize your hand stretched across Shayne's lap like a seat belt. He was terrified but you were protecting him. If you had any say in it you always would. 

Shayne must have noticed the protective way you were sitting because he laughed slightly, "My hero."

"Oh shut up, you're just making light of it to seem tough." You said moving your arm just as the final jump scared occurred. Elizabeth Bathory opens her eyes, and the game is entered (it's been a while and I'm doing this off of memory) by a new stupid player, restarting the deadly process. It's this quick moment that Shayne grabs your hand and pulls it back to where it previously rested, using the other to cover his face. 

You can't help but laugh at this but you're eyes show nothing but adoration as you softly asked, "Are you okay?"

He nods but it's a clear lie.

"Are you scared?" You ask sympathetically, not teasing, sincerely.  

Again he nods except this time it's truthful. 

Due to time, you decide to let him stay the night. Well, partially due to time. His wide eyes and shaken behavior was another deciding factor but for pride's sake, you say time. As he's a guest, you allow him to take your bed while you sleep on the couch. A few minutes later, while you're scrolling through Twitter on your phone, you see a shadow looming over you. Against your will you let out a squeak as you practically jump out of your skin. 

"I'm so sorry babe oh my god." Shayne quickly apologizes as you begin to laugh hysterically. 

"It's, fine. You're fine." Is all you get out between laughs before you clear your throat and continue, "what's up love?" 

"Umm, I just, umm..."

"You're still scared aren't you." You decide to help him out holding out a hand for him to help you up. He simply rubs the back of his neck sheepishly but that's more than enough conformation for you. 

"Can you uhh, stay with me. God I sound like a toddler. I'm fine, it's nothing." He begins to blush and keeps his hand on his neck. 

"Hey, that was a  creepy ass movie. You're fine. Of course I'll stay with you." You smile lovingly at him as you lift yourself ever so gently onto your toes and press your lips to his softly. You then slip your much smaller hand into his and walk to your bedroom. You lay facing each other at first but by the end of the night his arms are tightly around you and your head is on his chest, curled into him. If this was how you were going to wake up, you couldn't help but wonder, could every night be a scary movie night? And to tell you the truth, Shayne found the exact same silver lining.  

A/N i don't blame you for not reading if you don't want to but I just want to get out how much I appreciate the Smosh fam. Most other fandoms are like "I'll fight you, I love Harry Styles more than you do bitch" but this one is just like "let's help each other come up with ship names and share inside jokes and propose to a random stranger on the internet who shares interests. It's so healthy and lovely and just agh. Also I discovered how much I love creating ship names. Like legit send me a name and whoever they're into (it my oc marlee who i use for xreaders and damien is Dalee (like daily))  and i'll help come up with something (could be use to tease friends too 😈😂😂.) but yeah bye love y'all -marlee anne