My Husband's sister

The Good, the Bad, the Twins

Mariee's POV

It's been 6 months since my mom's funeral. I feel better since her killer is in jail serving his time. I lie in bed thinking about the situation until I hear Cat scream. I quickly jumped out of bed and ran down the hall towards her room. I grabbed the doorknob to turn it, but it was locked. I called Yo's name but she didn't answer, so I began to bang against the door until the lock broke. Once I finally got through the door, I saw the blankets on Cat's bed shuffling and moving around along with soft breathing. I yanked the covers back to see Cat naked with some random stud. I take a closer look and see Yo is the random stud. I gasp as Cat covers herself with the sheets, "Wait! Mariee, it's not what you think! I just... um... Yo was being too cute and wouldn't stop asking for a taste of my kitty!", Cat blurted out. I looked at Yo, who was seemingly unbothered by the situation and slapped her in the face. "How could you?! You told me as soon as she got here that nothing was going to happen! You fucking promised me! You promised me and said you loved me!", my tears began falling down my face as I looked at Cat, "And how could you just spread your legs open for her? You rejected her throughout high school, made her look like a fool at prom and then you turned around and fucked her best friend! But you got away with it because you're cute, adorable and you're Cat! I can't believe you!"

"I didn't want a girlfriend, Mariee, you know that.. I told her that a-", I cut her off by putting my hand up and pointing at the both of them. "There's nothing you can say or do that will make me forgive you for this, Cat. You stole her from me... again. How could..", "Hey I'm back! I bought KFC since Church's was too busy. Which was good because KFC is so much better." , I heard Yo's voice coming from downstairs. I quickly followed the sound and saw her and DJ setting out plates and chicken. "... Yo, what are you doing down here..?", I asked her. "Well you were mumbling about chicken and waffles in your sleep, fat ass. So DJ and I decided to go get chicken and make waffles so we can have a nice breakfast. Duh. DJ, get the batter out. Um...", she paused and examined me, "Why does it look like you were crying..?"  My eyes became wide as I heard Cat and the now unknown stud come downstairs. I heard Yo mumble "Shit." "Shit? What do you mean 'shit' ? Yo, what the fuck is going on?", Yo looked at me then told DJ to go to his room and play. "Well... this is not how I wanted the two of you to meet. Um... Mariee, Cat.. that's my twin sister.. Joelle, Jo for short.", Yo explained. I let out a sigh of relief and quickly hugged Yo tightly, "I knew you'd never cheat on me! I'm too good to cheat on!"
"That's debatable.", Yo teased causing me to punch her and then kiss her cheek. "Why didn't you tell me about her..?" "Well.. that's cause I thought she was... um..", she started getting nervous, then Jo spoke up. "Dead. Deceased. Passed away. Departed. Gone. No longer living. D-E-A-D. Dead. I faked my death to get out of going our bat shit crazy mother's house. As you can tell, it worked." I examined Jo closely and immediately saw a different between her and Yo. Jo had a birthmark on her chin which looked like a lightning bolt. Other then that one difference, the two were identical. "Well.. you can stay as long as you need to. We can let you sleep in the living room. Right, Yo?" I looked up to see Yo and Jo exchanging glares with Cat in the middle of both of them. I tugged on Yo's arm but quickly let go. What am I doing? Why am I acting this way? Even though it was Joelle I saw with Cat.. I feel like I need Yo closer to me .. I want her attention on me and DJ..
I snapped out of my thoughts when I felt Yo's lips on mine causing me to instantly blush once she pulled away. Jo smirked at me, "So you're the one who snatched my sister's heart huh? That's funny... Yo could pull a girl like you? You seem too hard to handle." I furrowed my eyebrows and was ready to respond back until Yo pinched my thigh making me jump and squeal. Yo looked at me then shook her head and started walking back to setting out plates.
This will be an interesting day..

~Later that Day~
I was laying on the couch with DJ taking his nap on my stomach. I flipped through the TV when Cat came downstairs in a pair of shorts that showed off her tiny booty and a crop top. She sat in the recliner next to me and began watching TV with me. "I'm sorry if you think that i'd try to take Yo away from you.. but there's something you should know.. when Jo was with me this morning, I knew she wasn't Yo. Not because of the birthmark but because I know that Yo wouldn't hurt you.. She really cares about you, Mariee. Plus their personalities are completely different, Yo is calm and patient while Jo is loud and obnoxious. I could tell the difference between them right away..", she told me. I looked over at her and smiled at the fact that she was right. Something felt off though, she didn't look at me the entire time she spoke and she sounded more serious than usual. Which only meant.
"Cat...", I began. She turned towards me with a bright red face and tears in her eyes. "Are... are you... are you in love with my girlfriend..?!"