Cartman x Reader *true feelings*

Telling the boys

You always sat with the boys. All day you could only think about the letter and who sent it. Questions began to form in your head like "what would they think", "would Kyle be out to get someone", and finally "what would Cartman think".

You sat down with the boys not bothering to get lunch. Kyle sat down next to you noticing the tears streaked down you face.

Kyle- whoa sis what happened?

(y/n)- I-I received a l-letter...

Kyle knew what she was talking about because he himself had helped Cartman write it last year, he had almost forgot it was there.

Kyle- are you going to read the letter out loud to the other guys I bet were all interested in who is trying to take away our favorite girl.

(y/n)- sure...

3rd pov

Cartman walked up with Stan, Kenny and Butters. Cartman saw the all familiar letter on the table hoping that (y/n) had liked what he had said, but then he saw the tears streaming down her face. What was wrong with the one that the letter was for. Had she found the one already or had she been so happy that someone loved her that she began to cry? He walked up to her trying to not show the concern on his face, so that he could confess that he was the writer of the letter later. Kenny however ran up to (y/n) and began to comfort her, Cartman prayed that she would not hug him back but moments into talking she did. His blood ran cold as Kenny walked back up to him and pulled him aside.

Kenny- Dude she found the letter you left her last year and she is so overwhelmed with joy she is crying!

Cartman- really? so I did not make her upset?

Kenny- no dude she's really happy, you seriously need to tell her she wants to be loved.

Cartman- how dude?

Kenny- write another letter, tell her where to meet and do something you.

Cartman- okay I will after school. First I am going to go comfort (y/n).

Cartman began to walk over to (y/n), seeing such a pretty, sweet and loving girl cry almost made him shed a tear, almost.

Cartman- hey (y/n) what up.

Suddenly you wrapped your arms around him crying on his shoulder. Cartman began to wrap his arms around your waist earning a slight glare from Kyle. Cartman whispered in your  ear telling you that it you would find him and that they would have a good life.  He also had told you that if anyone hurt her he would beat them to a pulp. You looked up to Cartman nodding your head in response to everything he had said.  

(y/n)'s pov

I was hugging Cartman when he started to say sweet things to me. I never knew he could be this kind to a Jew like me.  I was liking this side of him, even though I rarely got to see it. I could tell he was trying to be a nice person but he knew that others would dis on him for even trying.

I let go of him and nodded in response to his words whispering a calm 'thank you'.  Then I saw the thing I would only see this once, a genuine smile emerging on to his face. I smiled back, then the bell rang signaling to go to class. I walked away from the boys with a pep-in-my-step. I went to my next class and began to think about the letter, who could have said they loved me in such a sweet and poetic way?

time skip to after school near 5:00

(y/n) pov 

Kyle had left the house around 4:45 to go and play video games with Stan and Cartman. I was left alone with the letter. I tried to think about what to do with it, keep it or throw it away. I was already in love with Cartman so why would I need anyone else. Yet something felt so similar about the way it was written, the way it spoke. 

(y/n)- I'm keeping it, final decision.

Cartman's pov

Stan and Kyle were helping me write the letter that would make or break me and (y/n). I was happy that Kyle was going to help me, even if he was a dirty Jew (sorry it's what Cartman says).

Kyle-  Looking good now Cartman we wrote the letter, with help from your heart, even a little helps I guess.

Stan- Now you go home and prepare the picnic. Remember the list that Kyle gave you of her favorite foods. 

Cartman- yeah I got that, now I will be up cooking.

Kyle and Stan (in unison)- ARE YOU TRYING TO KILL HER FATASS!!!???

Cartman- no Stan and I am not fat you Jew! I am bigboooonnnedd!!! besides I already got my mom to help.....

Kyle- Promise me one thing okay?

Cartman- and what's that?

Kyle- you will be good to her..

Stan- don't pressure her, take your time with her...

Cartman- I love her more than anything in the world, but cheesy poofs are cutting it close, so I will.

Kyle hugged Cartman knowing that he might actually care for her. 

Stan- good luck Cartman.