Nightmare was dreaming about having fun with Error and a black cat named Black Rose. Nightmare was still enjoying his time with Error and Black Rose. They were all cuddling each other and Error was reading a book. Nightmare was cuddling with Black Rose. Outside Nightmares dream Error was hearing him talking in his sleep. Error now bought Nightmare a black cat and Error named it Black Rose. He knew when Nightmare woke up he would be excited. A Nightmare Sans woke up seeing Error holding a black cat. "I bought you a black cat and I named it Black Rose like in your dream." "How did you know about that dream?" "Night you talk in your sleep. That's is how I found out you wanted a black cat named Black Rose." "Oh thank you for my beautiful Black Rose. Also, I didn't know I talked in my sleep." "You're welcome Nighty." Nightmare cuddled with the cat and he loved listening to it purr. After a while Nightmare and Black Rose fell asleep together and Error watches thinking it looked cute so he took two pictures of them and he accidentally had his flash on. Nightmare stirred in his sleep but he didn't wake up. Thank me that Nightmare is a heavy sleeper. Nightmare smiled in his sleep as the cat cuddled against him. Nightmare was smiling when he opened his eyes because it is his birthday. Nobody noticed Nightmare because they were busy doing other things. Nightmare went to his room where his cat was. He started to cry because he feels unloved by everyone and Nightmare cried harder and harder every time. Nightmare was about to hurt himself but Error came into the room and stopped him. "I have a surprise for you. Follow me to the kitchen." "Okay sweetheart." Nightmare sounded more cheerful and he cleaned his face. Nightmare and Error went to the kitchen and then when Error turned on the lights. Nightmare was shocked that they all through him a birthday party. "You guys ignored me to set up a birthday party." "Yeah, it was Errors idea. We all bought presents for you." "Awe thank you, guys. This is also the best birthday ever. Thank you for the party sweetheart. Awe thank you for the cake as well." "No problem Nighty. I love you so much I had to throw you a party." Nightmare opened all his gifts and ate cake with his friends. That night he went to bed with pleasant dreams that night.