Once upon a time preferences

when you both realised you had feelings for each other

David:
David kind of had a attack of love at first sight. He just looked at you and fell in love

Also you had a attack of love at first sight, although you tried to deny it for yourself

Hook:
When Hook saw you standing there on his ship, while you were enjoying the sea and the fresh air, he realised it

When he taught you how to sail his schip and you were standing pretty close to him, you realised it

Rumpelstiltskin:
After quite some time, when you came to his castle again and he saw you, he realised he had feelings for you. This actually scared him, so except from a few moments he never showed those feelings to you

Also you developed feelings for him after some time, when you walked into his castle again. You saw a man behind the monster, something he didn't see himself

Peter Pan:
When his shadow brought you to the Island and he saw you, he already felt something special. After some time, he suddenly realised he had feelings for you

When the shadow dropped you of and you got to know Pan, you already felt happy. He was the only one who could make you feel complete again

Felix:
He spend more and more time with you after a while, since you also became second in command. When you were both send on a mission together, he began to realise he had feelings for you

Same as Felix. You were both on a mission and you began to realise your feelings for him

August:
August didn't know you were his cat Figaro, but he did felt a weird connection with you when you met the first time. It was almost like you already knew each other. While you were both enjoying a delicious meal and Granny's, he realised his feelings for you

Just like August, you felt a weird connection between the two of you. The moment you both were enjoying your meal and Granny's and talked to each other, you realised your feelings for him

Jefferson:
When he saw you playing a game with his daughter Grace, he realised he had feelings for you.

After visiting Jefferson more often and playing games with his daughter, you realised your feelings for him.

Jiminy:
The moment you accidently bumped into him and he looked at you, he already felt something. When he saw you walking down the street the next day and you smiled at him, he realised his feelings for you

Same as Jiminy. You saw him walking down the street with his dog the next day and realised you had feelings for him

Victor:
After you woke up, you two spend some time together. One night, when you two were walking through the garden and he looked at you, he realised that he had feelings for you.

While you both were walking through the garden and something scared you there (it was an animal who accidently ran past), he grabbed your hand to comfort you. That was the moment you realised your feelings for him