Two of a Kind

The one that got away

Derek watched with a frown as Stiles threw on a nice shirt and a pair of khaki pants. He tried not to stare too hard at the twin as he dressed. The twins weren't built like Derek, but they were lean and definitely attractive.

"You don't think I should go," Stiles guess by Derek's disapproving look.

"I can just tell you don't want to," Derek shrugged. He wasn't honestly sure if he was okay with Stiles going or not. On one hand he was glad it wasn't Spencer, but then on the other hand, he kind of wished it was instead. He really needed to sort himself out.

"I like Theo, or well I did. It's been years since I've really seen him, so I don't know if I like him. Even back then I knew he wasn't someone I would date. He was popular with all the guys. He'd hit on at least six different people just in the few hours I saw him at that party." Stiles shrugged pulling on his shoes.

"But he kissed you?" Derek asked. He saw a blush fill Stiles' cheeks.

"Yeah, I think I was playing hard to get and he took it as a challenge. I was surprised when he kissed me. A bunch of us were standing there, watching the fireworks. When they set off the finale, he pulled me in. I could practically feel the hatred and jealousy from the other guys he'd flirted with," Stiles' stomach flipped just thinking about that kiss. He'd been elated and felt honestly special, but he knew it was just a one-time thing. Well until now.

"If you need anything, call me. I know Spencer has a study session with one of his classes, but I'm not doing anything," Derek offered. He didn't know why he offered, maybe he really didn't like the idea that this Theo guy was really into Stiles.

"Thanks, Derek," Stiles smiled before heading out the door.

-

Stiles sat anxiously at the table waiting for Theo to show up. Stiles had text Kai on his way, letting him know the place and time. He hoped Kai came through.

"You look amazing," Theo's voice said causing Stiles to look up.

"Uh, thanks, so do you," Stiles gave a shy smile. His stomach flipped at the sight of the guy. He really didn't look the same at all. He'd grown up in all the right ways.

"I'm really glad you agreed to meet me," Theo gave a large grin as he took his seat across from Stiles.

"I'm just surprised you remember me," Stiles shifted in his seat.

"Are you kidding me? You were the one that got away," Theo laughed lightly.

"The one that got away?" Stiles tilted his head curiously.

"Of course. You had me hooked at that party. I took a huge step kissing you. I was sure you didn't like me like that, but when you didn't pull away, I thought maybe I had a chance. I wanted to keep in contact, but you left before I could give you my number," Theo looked nervous as he spoke.

Stiles bit his lip, he recalled leaving very quickly after and not telling anyone, "I just thought you saw me as an easy target," Stiles shrugged.

"Easy target?" Theo scoffed with a smile, "I spent the whole night chasing you around. I flirted with every guy I could to make you jealous. You barely acknowledged me."

"You were pretty popular with all those guys, I assumed you were just frustrated cause I wasn't giving you the attention you wanted," Stiles admitted. Perhaps he'd been wrong about Theo.

"Oh I was very frustrated, but only because the only attention I wanted was yours," Theo smirked, dropping his eyes to his menu.

Stiles followed suit, his heart racing. Maybe Theo wasn't the type of person he thought.

"Anyway, enough about the past, tell me about yourself," Theo urged setting his menu aside.

-

Stiles found himself enjoying his dinner with Theo, in fact he'd barely noticed how much time had passed, that was until the waiter brought the check over.

"This is for you, whenever you're ready," The waiter smiled before disappearing.

Stiles reached for the book at the same time as Theo.

"I invited you to dinner so I pay," Theo shook his head, sliding the little black book away from Stiles.

Stiles was about to open his mouth to thank Theo for dinner when Kai approached the table.

"Stiles, hey babe," Kai grinned leaning down and placing a kiss to Stiles' cheek.

"Oh, uh, Kai, hey," Stiles had completely forgotten he'd asked Kai to crash the date.

Theo's brows rose at the intruder.

"Who's your friend?" Kai gestured to Theo then.

"Theo," He introduced himself.

"Oh, he hasn't mentioned you," Kai frowned crossing his arms over his chest.

"We go way back," Theo winked at Stiles then earning a blush.

"That's cool. It's always good to catch up with old friends. Speaking of, are we still on for Friday?" Kai asked turning a flirty smile to Stiles.

"Uh, Friday?" Stiles frowned.

"The party?" Kai reminded him.

"Oh, right, yeah, of course," Stiles nodded avoiding Theo's confusion.

"Great, tell Derek and Spencer I said hi," Kai leaned in for another kiss, this time placing his lips at the corner of Stiles' mouth.

Stiles cleared his throat nervously once Kai walked off, "Sorry about that," Stiles bit his lip anxiously. He kind of felt bad. He'd actually enjoyed his date with Theo and he felt like he'd kind of ruined it.

"I didn't realize you were seeing someone," Theo spoke with a slight frown.

"Oh, no that's not..." Stiles shook his head, "He's just..." He trailed off.

"So I have competition is what you're telling me," Theo asked with a smirk.

"Competition?" Stiles asked in surprise. He'd been sure Theo would be upset and end whatever this was starting between them.

"This party, is anyone invited?" Theo asked.

"Uh, yeah It's at his dorm room," Stiles nodded.

"Great, maybe I'll swing by," Theo smiled, leaning back in his chair.

"Oh, uh, okay, sure, I'll get you a flier," Stiles wasn't sure if he should try and salvage this potential relationship or not, but he kind of liked Theo and he didn't seem to be the type of person he'd initially thought. Maybe dating Theo wouldn't be such a bad idea.

*AN*
A little drama for ya.