Red Dead Redemption 2 x Reader

Hunting for satisfaction (Arthur x f!Reader x Charles, Lemon)

"You wanna go huntin' with us?" An all so familiar voice called you. Looking over your shoulder you saw Arthur and Charles waiting by the horse.
"Yes!" You shouted excitedly, grabbing your bag as you got up from the log you were sitting on. "But ain't it a lil bit late?"
"We'll be fine, come on." Charles said softly as ever and pulled you up on his horse. You loved both men dearly, always so quiet and collected. They often took you out on hunting trips since you loved observing and drawing animals from afar. Sometimes you caught yourself staring at their toned bodies more than wildlife. Your nose buried into Charles' hair, it still smelled fresh and pleasant.
"What are we searching for?" You chanted happily and wrapped your hands around his middle.
"We'll see." Arthur yelled from on top of his horse.

The trip was pretty unsuccessful. You only managed to catch two rabbits, but you also got some pretty neat photos that you could sell for a pretty penny. Setting up a small camp on the flat landscape, you spread out some comfy blankets around the fireplace before dropping down on them. The men joined you shortly after placing down a tent.
"It smells like rain." Charles said whilst carefully separating the meat off the rabbit.
"Some call it petrichor." You said looking down at his skilled hands.
"Come on y/n, you know that we don't know what it means." Arthur jumped into the calm conversation. A small smile formed on your lips and you leaned your head against Charles' shoulder.
"It's just this sweet aroma after rain hits the ground." They both admired you for your brains and that you're not flaunting it around, but rather help them understand. After you saw Arthur scribbling in his journal you searched your bag only to notice that you forgot yours. Eyes focused on you, he paused for a few seconds just to look at you. The silence between you was nice, you understood each other without talking much. Well, neither of them were talkative anyways.
"Y/n." Charles grumbled and placed a little piece of cooked meat against your lips. It was still slightly warm, perfect temperature for consumption.
"It's really good!" You said within chews and got a low hum as a response. Both of them were always so gentle towards you, and you knew how mean and brutal they can be. Nevertheless, you enjoyed every moment of their company and deep down you hoped that something else could spring to life between you three.
"You alright there y/n?" Arthur chuckled after he saw your red face.
"Y-yes I'm alright." You stuttered and jerked away from Charles' shoulder.
"I was just thinking, that's all." Thumbs fiddled together nervously as Arthur sat down next to you.
"'Bout what?"
"Well uhm, I." It was hard to keep it together, you were sure that he blew your cover by now.
"I like you!" You burst out of your shell as you turned around to face Charles, he looked rather sad.
"You too." Slowly calming down after you felt his hand on your naked leg.
"We both knew." Your head bounced back onto his shoulder after you calmed down. Your heart outran your brain and you planted a small kiss on the cheek on each men. Eyes widened as Arthur grabbed your chin, pulling your lips against his.
"We like you too." He said breathily against your mouth.
"A lot." Charles added and gently stroked your calf as he roasted the rest of the rabbit. You never felt this loved before, being caressed by the two men you've been longing for elevated your senses.
"Arthur..." His hands trailed down to your waist, pushing deeper into the kiss, sometimes slipping tongue.
"Take your time with her please." Charles demanded whilst placing the meat in some tin bowls.
"Eat first." It was amazing how he made simple food into something amazing and so flavorful. Merely taking a few minutes to finish your meal, you wiped your mouth and eyed both men.
"Come here." Charles said hastily and cupped your face before kissing you sensually. He was just as eager to kiss you as Arthur was a few minutes back. Hands tangled in his long black hair, his tongue lapped against your hungrily. Heat already pooled between your legs after you felt another mouth breathing down your neck. You were pulled forcefully into Arthur's lap as he licked and sucked on your neck. Charles followed you, recapturing the kiss, groping one of your breasts. He exhaled through his nose and groaned after he felt your nipples harden through the thin fabric.
"No bra?"
"I wanted to go to sleep anyways." You switched to Arthur's mouth as Charles slowly unbuttoned your blouse, leaving kisses all over your chest. You couldn't help but giggle and moan at all the gentle attention you received from them. The latter turning them on even more of course.
"I had my eyes on you for a long time." He said and circled around your nipple with his tongue making you grab onto his head. Making his way down to your shorts he asked for permission before pulling them off. You swiftly pressed your thighs together in embarrassment.
"Don't be shy." Arthur said in between kisses.
"We'll treat you right." Charles added, both waited for your next action. Slowly, you spread your legs for him. It was embarrassing opening up to someone without having four walls around you. At this point you were a shuddering mess, desperately gripping at the clothes and hair of your lovers. Charles was busy peppering your left thigh with kisses whilst Arthur played with your boobs. One of his hands left your chest and caressed your right thigh.
"I love how you sing for us." Arthur whispered into your ear as he squeezed your soft skin. You nuzzled your face against his neck, trying to muffle your moans.
Charles' thumb ran over the wet spot on your panties, making your legs quiver with excitement. They both loved teasing you, it feels nice to take a break from all the mayhem at the camp. So they might as well enjoy it and take their time with you.
"You're so pretty." Charles said after he pushed your panties aside. One finger moved up and down your wet sex.
"Fuck..." Arthur cursed under his breath as his finger joined Charles' one, exploring your folds on his own. He spread your lips with two fingers before Charles stretched you out with his thick digits. A loud moan jumped out of your throat as he curled his fingers upwards against your sweet spot. Some droplets of rain fell on your almost naked form.
"Should we go into the tent?" You softly said, still dazed by all the pleasure and attention. With a soft nod behind you, Arthur crawled on top of the sleeping rolls. Charles grabbed your butt as you followed Arthur. Your lips puckered against his cheek as you unbuttoned his shirt, sliding it over his broad shoulders. It's a rare sight to see him so content and comfortable as you ran your hands over his torso. Dark hairs arrowed down to the bulge in his pants and you couldn't stop staring at it as you palmed it.
"Get rid of this, please." You whispered into his ear before you turned around to face Charles. He already pulled off his shirt, giving you access to his sculpted chest. Both men needed you, badly. They've been yearning for some skin-to-skin contact for so long and you were happy to deliver. Pressing your chest against Arthur, you gripped around his cock, making him emit some low moans.
"Kiss me." You said to Charles as you repeatedly bumped against his crotch. The image of you being so worked up brought a grin to Arthur's face, slowly moving your hand up and down his cock.
"Don't be with anybody else but us." Charles mumbled as he devoured your soft lips and mouth. "I just might kill them then." You never knew that he was so possessive, but it charmed you anyways.
"C'mere. I can't wait no more." Arthur said, his hands reached out for your waist. With seductive eyes, you carefully climbed on top of him, body twitching after you felt two tips against you soaking cunt.
"Relax y/n. Your heart is beating out of your chest." Charles said breathlessly,  not being able to hide his excitement any longer. They both pushed into you at the same time, straining your tight pussy. After some adjusting and waiting the two cocks were buried inside of you.
"You're doing so good."
"Y-yeah?" You could only moan as a reply. Charles's dick was longer than Arthur's, but he was thicker. Making it only harder for you to adjust to the massive stretch. Four hands were fervently gripping at your body as you slowly bounced up and down, sobbing at the immense pleasure and pain. With every movement inside of you, they jabbed against your g-spot.
"You're so soft y/n." Arthur said, pulling you down with him to get a better angle to push into you. As you were sandwiched by the two men, you could swear that you almost came once or twice.
"Oh god." You cried out and collapsed onto Arthur's body, drooling and moaning against his neck. A hand desperately grabbed at his fibers as the other one caressed Charles's shoulder behind you. Their hot bodies rubbing up against you made you go crazy. Arthur was losing his composure slowly but surely, thrusting into you harder and at a faster pace. The rain was gushing out of the sky and slowly extinguished the campfire, leaving you clothed in a dim light.
"Jesus fucking Christ." You whined as you were being mercilessly pounded by your two new lovers. The danger of being caught only made you moan louder and louder with every thrust. Your head jerked up in the air as you came around both dicks.
"Feeling good?" Charles murmured breathlessly into your ear before nipping at it. Sweat rolled down your body as you felt Arthur finishing inside of you before slipping out.
"You're getting old." Charles chuckled at Arthur.
"Shut up." He said and shuffled backwards, eyes glued to your irresistible face as you were being fucked out of your mind by Charles. His dick left your quivering pussy, leaving you with a frown on your face.
"Get on your back." He purred whilst cracking his knuckles. The intimidating look of him was soon washed away by his loving embrace, sliding into you once more. Arthur's hands caressed your face from behind as Charles pressed his warm upper body against your breasts. Legs wrapped around his waist almost instantly and your hands clawed at his back, leaving scratches on his flawless skin. He growled against your neck as he passionately pounded into you whilst Arthur lovingly tidied your messy hair. Half-lidded eyes hopelessly searched for his face before your attention was drawn back to Charles who was still impatiently thrusting into you. His black hair felt like pure silk between your fingers as you pulled his face up. His lusting gaze focused on your flushed face, he was exhausted and near his climax. Plump lips crashed against each other, hungrily exchanging spit. It didn't take a long time before he couldn't control himself and his breathing became ragged and uneven, praising you with every thrust.
"There we go." Charles moaned loudly as he spilled himself inside of you.
"Did you cum again?" He asked whilst pressing soft kisses against your cheek. You shook your head and winced as he pulled out. Rubbing your thighs together, you yearned for any kind of satisfaction. Charles's rough hand lifted your thigh and Arthur joined you on the other side, running his hand down your stomach to your clit.
"Don't worry, we gotchu." He whispered into your ear as he circled around your sweet spot at a medium pace. The semen inside of you oozed out due to Charles's huge fingers entering you. Their rough motions were contrasted by the sweet kisses they left all over your face and chest. Just a few minutes later, you were a moaning and quivering mess again.
"Charles..." You whined as he hit your g-spot over and over again.
"You close?" Arthur murmured against your ear and sped up.
"Arthur... fuck." Hands gripped tight around the heads of your lovers. You arched your back in pleasure and pressed your face into his neck.
"So shaky." Charles said and added another finger. Your whole body shuddered as you experienced your second orgasm of the night. After you spazzed around his fingers he brought them up to your face. Obediently, you swirled your tongue around it, cleaning the mess you three made. Rolling on your side, the two men started stroking your exhausted form. You could feel every inch of their skin against your body, exchanging the warmth between you. It was so comfortable, you could feel how you slowly slipped into your dreams.
"Good night." They both whispered and you fell asleep shortly after.

You awoke to Arthur's smiling face nuzzling yours.
"Good morning sleepy head." He said and kissed you passionately. Climbing on top of him, you smooched his face.
"You want some coffee?" Charles said from behind you.
"Yes please!" Your hand reached out of the tent, you were too scared that somebody else would see you since you were still in your birthday suit. He sat next to you offering you the cup before exchanging a few kisses.
"We have to go hunting more often." Arthur chuckled and stroked your crossed legs. And you couldn't agree more.