judging criteria

158 16 3
                                    

Here is the Judging Criteria

Oops! This image does not follow our content guidelines. To continue publishing, please remove it or upload a different image.


Here is the Judging Criteria. Please fill up all of it and pm it to me. Please be fair in judging. There will be five parts in the Judging Criteria.

I. Book's Info

Book Title:
Category:
Author:

II. Book's Outer Appearance

Is the Book Cover appealing or appropriate to the story? [5/5]
Is the Book Title appealing or appropriate to the story? [5/5]
Does the description relates to the story? [10/10]

III. Book's Inner Appearance

Does the first chapter captivates you or wants you to read more? [15/15]
Is the story so good and makes you want to recommend it to someone? [35/35]
Is the story plot messy and all over the place or well-organized and thought-out? [15/15]
Are there any grammatical and spelling errors? [5/5]
Does the story makes you feel any kind of emotion? [10/10]

IV. Book's Hidden Appearance
(You can just skip this part if you want to. This part will be just purely your opinions regarding the story. This opinions will be sent to the respective author if you permit it, of course. No pressure fam! 💜)

Do you have any suggestions or opinions regarding the book's cover, title and description?
Any suggestions or opinions regarding the plot and the way it was delivered?
Additional message regarding the story or words of encouragement to the author?

V. Book's Overall

Total rating: 100/100
Thumbs up or Thumbs down

Example:

I. Book's Info

Book Title: I Will Be Here
Category: JIN
Author: ipurplebts

I. Book's Outer Appearance

Is the Book Cover appealing or appropriate to the story? [3/5]
Is the Book Title appealing or appropriate to the story? [4/5]
Does the description relates to the story? [7/10]

II. Book's Inner Appearance

Does the first chapter captivates you or wants you to read more? [9/15]
Is the story so good and makes you want to recommend it to someone? [26/35]
Is the story plot messy and all over the place or well-organized and thought-out? [10/15]
Are there any grammatical and spelling errors? [4/5]
Does the story makes you feel any kind of emotion? [7/10]

III. Book's Hidden Appearance

Do you have any suggestions or opinions regarding the book's cover, title and description? The palette used in the book cover should be more lighter and softer since the story is a fluff one. Description needs to be more captivating. It doesn't need to be long as long as it has a great impact and is related to the plot.
Any suggestions or opinions regarding the plot and the way it was delivered? There are a few plot holes here and there, but it can be improved. I suggest that the author rereads the whole story since there are quite a few grammatical and spelling errors.
Additional message regarding the story or words of encouragement to the author? It was good overall, but it's still has rooms for improvement and that's a good thing! I hope the author take this criticism in a good way and be an inspiration for the author to keep writing more.

IV. Book's Overall

Total rating: 73/100
Thumbs up

"Be Wise and Fair."

Purple Lights Awards 2019 | CLOSEDWhere stories live. Discover now