The Cheshire Hatter (Jeff the Killer x Oc x Homicidal Liu)

Him... And Helen Otis?

It's been a while since... Jeff's death... I can't stop thinking about it. It's my fault he's dead yet he still loved me to the end of his life. I- I wish this all couldn't have happened. I wish I was normal, like the other girls. I wish I wasn't magic born. If I could take it all away. That dream last night...

Yeah! That amazing dream... if it was real. I could kill for it. A reality just like this one. But our stories retold. Jeff alive but not my boyfriend, sally being my little sister, and Lui being the true friend I needed. Yet, all said and done. I can't wish for that. 

I sat in my bed again. I wonder, what truly happened to Jeff? Does his spirit live on within another? Did he pass on to another universe? I'm going crazy again. 

Did I hear a knock at my window? Who could that be? It's about three am and everyone is asleep. I slid down my bed and carefully went to the window. I couldn't see anything behind the curtain. Surely no one is hiding or trying to kill me. Auntie Red isn't mad anymore so who would want me dead? 

I slowing pulled the curtain away. I saw a box. It was a purple and blue box. I slid the window up. I pulled the box into my arms. The box, small but beautiful. I stared into its beauty. I noticed it was for me. They used Luna instead of Luner. How did someone get my true name? I never told anyone besides Jeff, Sally, and Slender. I opened the box. I saw a drawing; a drawing of me sleeping? What the hell!?! Even if the idea was creepy, the picture was drawn very well. I looked into the box more in case there was more than the drawing. I was right. 

Inside was a choker and a note. It was a simple thin ribbon choker. The choker was black but matched my outfit nicely. I loved it! I'm going to wear it every day. Then the note was the last thing the box had. I opened the note up. It read...

Dear Luner or Luna

I know you don't know me. I wish I could tell you who I was. I liked you for a while. I overheard Ben and Slender saying your true name. I know, I'm being creepy. I've liked you for a while now. I hated when I saw you with Jeff. I know Jeff never gets anything but seeing him happy with you hurt me. I knew I couldn't do anything. I wanted to know you. I didn't want to seem like the man to take another man's happiness. I wish would like to say I  mourned his death but... something awoke inside of me. I could have a chance with you. But I knew that winning your love wouldn't be easy. I asked my friends to help with the present. The drawing was with the guidance of Bloody painter or Helen Otis. The choker Clockwork helped me pick out with her "girl intuition" The coloring for the present, was your "little sister" Sally's idea. I mean, the girl does have a good eye for what you like. Luner, I like you. Maybe one day I'll talk to you and tell you. Now it isn't the right time. You're not okay right now. I'll wait, just know I'm here. 

-Signed Your Secret Admirer  

I dropped the note. What!?! Someone within this mansion likes me. I didn't know what to say back then but I knew what I did next was the right step in the right direction.

I fell asleep. I knew the plan I had for finding who this was. I wound find Helen and ask her about this. Little did I know... Helen was a boy. 

I woke up and went down to greet everyone. They were shocked to see me. I could hear the whispers like "Is she okay?" "Do you think Jeff's death really affect her too much?" "Did she get over it that quickly?" "I wonder if this is just a cover-up for her?"

"Hello, Luner!" greeted the Slenderman. "How are you feeling?" "I'm doing fine, actually," I replied. For once that wasn't a lie. This secret admirer is actually making me happier. "Sissy!" exclaimed Sally. Her eyes glowed brighter. Everyone has recovered. See them happy, made me feel happy. This time I noticed more about them. Jane and Clockwork are very close. I swear they were close to kissing. Toby, Masky, and Hoodie were getting along. Lui was talking to Skroll, Lulu was having a nice time talking to Jack, over in another corner Lj and Laughing Jill were sharing tips about candy. Lj and Laughing Jill are so cute! I could feel a small hand pulling on my leg. I looked down to see sally trying to get my attention. I knelt down to see her, face to face. "Can I please have some yummy sweets?" asked Sally. I looked over at Slender, he held a thumbs up. He knew his face was unreadable, so he would give me a thumbs up instead. "Sure!" Pulling out cookies out of my hat, I created safe cookies for Sally. 

"Yay!" squealed Sally. Her smile, she was one of the only things that kept me going these days. I approached the Slenderman again. "Slender, where does Helen Otis live?" I asked. "Helen lives a few doors left from your's." He replied. "Thanks!" I said before rushing to find her room. Little did I know, Slender was trying to tell me Helen was a man. The other chuckled. "She's going to have one hell of a surprise." one said inside the kitchen. 

I raced over to the room. Bloody Painter or Helen Otis. I knocked on the door. No answer. I held my ear to the door. Inside I could hear a pencil being scraped on a piece of paper. She was definitely drawing something at the moment. "Hello? Helen?" I asked. No reply for a few minutes. "What do you want?" asked a quiet voice of a man?!? "Um... is Helen here?" I asked. The man chucked. "You were here to see Helen, eh." "Yep! Where is she?" I asked the man. "Come inside. I'll unlock the door." said the man. I stepped back. 

The door opened. I saw a man. He had jet black hair, pale skin, blue eyes, a blue jacket with a black shirt, and blue jeans. The jacket has a cute yellow smiley. He was kinda cute. What am I thinking? Blush went apon my cheeks. 

"Um... are you going to stand here?" asked the man. "Where's Helen?" I asked. "I'm Helen," he said. Wait what!?! Helen isn't a woman, Helen's a boy! "Come inside, I'll explain this to you, Luner." I walked into his room. For being a killer, his room was quite neat. "Luner, you're the girl he was talking about. That boy, he came in and asked me for lessons on drawing. He held a picture of you sleeping. Creepy yet odd to me. He liked you for while now." He said. "Why is your name Helen," I asked. "My parents wanted a girl. They named me Helen and made me wear girly clothes for most of my life. One day they let me be myself instead of their doll." Helen replied. He was a killer like everyone here, but he was definitely deeper within himself. 

"Thanks for the info, Helen." I thanked him and left. What nice boy I though. Helen went back to his drawing. 

Meanwhile........

In a dark place. Something woke with the slumber. A man came out. Blood dripping down his face, dark hair now messy and bloody, clothing with holes and tears. His body was full of scars from a dark machine. Then the king of evil approached him. The devil with the shadows... Zalgo. Zalgo followed by The Rakes. He went to the newly woken man. 

"Your time has come for vengeance!" exclaimed Zalgo.  The man gave an evil laugh. He has a smile that signaled who it was...  

Jeff the killer... arose from the dead.

To be continued...

Author's Note

Hey! It's been a while. I slowly have gotten back into the creepypasta franchise. The last chapter was a dream thing now. But Luna is Luner's real name. I love this story a lot. This was the first book or story I've ever written. This time, I will see it to the end. I have two main ideas for the ending and how the story will go. I'm going to make two main love interests in this story. In the end, you choose who you like. (Just Jeff or Liu.)