Supernatural Boyfriend/Girlfriend Scenarios

You Find Out What He Is

Gabriel:
     You couldn't believe it!
     You thought you and Gabriel had an agreement but apparently not since he decided to go after another person who he killed.
    Now you and your brothers were stuck in TV land, just trying to figure out how to make it to the next TV the trickster would put you in. 
    At one point, Sam stabbed him and you thought you had won until the next morning when you woke up to find that Sam had disappeared, only to find that he had merged with the impala.
    You and Dean drove to a place where he thought he could trap the trickster. You both got out the impala and Dean shouted, "Alright you son of a bitch! You win! Uncle!"
    "Please come, Tricks!" There was no answer.
    "Should I honk?" Sam asked.
    Suddenly, the trickster appeared, walking up. "Hey, Sam. Get a load of the rims on you!"
    "Eat me!"
    He whistled. "Tricks." You called him by his nickname. 
    He turned his attention to you. "Hi, sugar. Missed me?"
    "Turn Sam back, please." You begged.
    "As you wish, sugar."
    He snapped his fingers and Sam suddenly got out the car. You ran to hug him, happy to see him again. Dean got into a conversation with the trickster, explaining that he knew he wasn't actually a trickster but an angel instead. Sam threw a lighter at his feet, making holy fire around him.
    Suddenly, you, your brothers, and the supposed angel were transported back to the warehouse where the whole thing started. 
    "You are!" you shouted, getting Tricks' attention. "You're an angel! Who are you?"
    He looked at you, his golden gaze burning into yours, an apologetic look in them. "Gabriel. They call me Gabriel, sweetheart."
    "Gabriel? The archangel?"
    He smiled. "I told you that you were the smart one."

Sam:
    You were still running from Abaddon.
    One day, she finally caught up to you. She had brought so many demons that you couldn't fight them all off, even with all your powers. Two of them grabbed you and brought you to Abaddon.
    "Oh (y/n), dear, did you really think you could escape from me?" She leaned in and whispered, "I will destroy you and then I will destroy your pathetic father."
    She then got her dagger, prepared to kill you when a few shots rang out. The two guards holding you fell to the ground, dead. Abaddon turned toward the people who shot the guards. While she was distracted, you grabbed her dagger and stabbed her, killing her.
    Two men approached you, one of them very familiar. "Detective Branson?"
    He looked a little uncomfortable. "Actually, that's not my name. I'm Sam Winchester. This is my brother, Dean."
    "You're the famous Winchesters? You're hunters!" Sam nodded.
    "You're right, sweetheart." Dean said.
    "I think we have a lot to talk about."

Dean:
    One day, your brother called you to come find him, all frantic. Immediately, you appeared in the middle of nowhere. You saw your brother fighting alongside two other guys, one of which you recognized as Dean. You joined them, fighting the angry pack of djinn they'd managed to get themselves into.
    Once the fight was over, Cas introduced you to the boys. "Dean?"
    "(Y/n)?"
    "You two know each other?" Cas asked, looking mad.
    "Sort of." you confessed.
    Cas introduced you to Dean's brother, Sam, who was super tall, and explained that they were both hunters.

Cas:
    You already knew.