Chapter 1

1.4K 35 4
                                    

"Oh my god that feels good." Charlotte was screaming in the back of her boyfriend car while laying on her back getting fuck.

"Aww shit I'm about to cum!" Seth said pumping a few more times before cumming on the girl underneath him.

Sometimes Charlotte felt like she was whore but she wasn't. She loves Seth and Seth loves her. That's the only thing should matter right? But it's not Charlotte was in love with the school freak, the chick with the dick her next door neighbor Sasha Banks. Charlotte couldn't never see herself being in a real relationship with Sasha. She's straight and Sasha is gay; just because they live next door to each other for most of their lives and had sleepovers and baths together when they were little kids doesn't mean they were meant for each other. Low-key if Charlotte could and would she would date Sasha. Just like know doesn't know Sasha her first everything and I mean her first everything. Her first kiss all the way to losing her virginity even though Seth thinks he popped her cherry but he didn't Sasha did and she will always cherish that moment with her.

Sasha is special to her and if anyone at school mess around with her brown eyed puppy it will be hell to pay. And that includes her boyfriend who picks fights with her on a daily basis for no reasons and Roman just sit there and let's it happens.

After wiping his cum off of Charlotte; Seth tuck himself back into his pants before handling Charlotte her clothes to put back on.

"You okay?" Seth asked as he climbs into the front seat.

"Yeah I'm just tired could you take me home? I'm not feeling well." Charlotte said as she fastened her seatbelt.

"Are you sure you okay? I don't want you to mad in the morning when I come to pick you?" Seth ask as he kills the engine to his car.

What Charlotte suppose to say? She was thinking about Sasha the whole time he was fucking. She felt like a whore fucking in the backseat of car in the middle of nowhere.

"Lexie is giving me a ride to school." She  quickly rushed without him a goodnight kiss.

Unlocking the front door Charlotte made her way upstairs to room closing the door behind she didn't want to hear her mother questioning her where she been. Charlotte is a good girl, smart, nice, friendly and head cheerleader along with her best friend Alexa.

"I thought you said you're staying home." A voice said through the darkness of her room.

"Shit Banks you scared me!" Charlotte screamed while turning around and holding on to her chest.

Sasha was sitting in the dark waiting on the blonde's bed when she walked.

"I didn't know you were my mother now?'' She said crossing her arms over her chest as she was eyeing Sasha.

"And I didn't literally sit here for two hours waiting on you, but I did!" Sasha said snapping at the blonde.

"And I didn't ask for the attitude neither. You can leave if you want, I really don't care." She said rolling her eyes at the light skin girl.

Sasha got up from the bed and made her way over to the door before looking over at the blonde.

"Uh no the same way you came in." Charlotte said pointing to her bedroom window.

Rolling her eyes Sasha purposely shoulder bump with Charlotte for no reason. "I don't know why I even bothering trying with you." Sasha says under her breath as she crawls out of the two stories house window.

Great you always screwing things up with her. Just admit you are gay and you are in love with Sasha. You always have and you always will, this isn't a phase and you know it isn't. Your mother wouldn't care; nobody wouldn't care but you! Charlotte self conscious was telling herself as she stares at herself in the bathroom mirror.

Torn In Between The Two (Wwe)Where stories live. Discover now