!Yandere! Jason The Toymaker x !Shy! Reader

Chapter 9

You wake up to an empty bed. You look around the room to make sure Jason isn't in so you can change. You see he isn't around so you get up and change into your casual clothes. Then you walk out to where the couch is and see Jason sitting down with someone else.

The other man had grey skin, long black hair and glowing yellow eyes. He wore a grey hoodie with a black coat over it and a grey beanie. He look kinda..... Cute to be honest.

"Jason?" you say and both of them turn to you. "Oh hi Lizzy." Jason says and smile. "So your Lizzy. Nice to meet you I'm puppeteer, but you can call me pup for short." the man with grey skin said. You smile and wave slightly, "H-h-hi Pup." you say stuttering a little.

Jason chuckles a bit, "No need to be nervous around good old pup. He's nice." he says walking over to you kissing your forehead. You smile slightly and take a seat next to pup as Jason goes to make you something to eat.

"So your his Lizzy? He talks about you all the time." pup says to you with a yellow glowing smile. "I'm not his Lizzy. My names Elizabeth Baker and I want to get out of here." you say leaning back into the couch.

Pup frowns a bit, "Jason's not a bad guy.... He just needs love and attention." he says putting a hand on your shoulder. You sigh, "But he has you, LJ, and Candy Pop." you say looking at the ceiling. "Just give him a chance." pup says and stood up leaving.

You thought about what Pup said, "Give him a chance." you sigh as you think about how kind Jason is to you. Even if he is keeping you here against your own freewill.

Jason comes back with a plate of eggs and toast and gives it to you. You smile and take the plate as Jason sits  next to you. You start eating as Jason watches you. After you finish Jason takes your hand and holds it. You look at him and smile slightly.

'Maybe I could give him a chance.' You think to yourself. Jason grabs the plate and walks away as you sit on the couch and think. He comes back with a small box and gives it to you, "I remembered it was your birthday so I got you a gift." he said as you took the box and opened it.

The glass rose that Jason got you a few days ago was in the box, "I thought I left it at the restaurant?!" you say shocked. Jason giggled, "You did, I saw it while we were leaving and quickly grabbed it." he said with a smile.

You don't know why, but you hugged Jason and he hugged back. "Happy birthday Elizabeth." he said letting go of you. "You called me Elizabeth?!" you said surprised. "I thought you didn't like Lizzy." he said. You bite down on your lip, you were always mean to him every time he called you Lizzy.

"Lizzy is fine." you say a slightly blush covering your face.