MLP CAT-Tastrophe

How?

(author's note: this is my first fan-fiction writing, so if it isn't that good, don't be mean about it plz!)

"OW!" Jelly Jam yelped. "What the heck did you just throw at me?!" She turned to me. She was only greeted with the loud laughter bursting out of my mouth. "It's not funny, Tatertot!" she shouted at me as she pulled the moss off her face. Bolt Slash entered the area. Him being the only one aware of being different creatures than usual, he shouted "Doesn't anyone notice that we're CATS?!"
"Oh! That's what that potion did!" a familiar voice exclaimed. Watermelon entered the area looking ashamed. Bolt Slash and I shouted "What is that supposed to mean?!" at her. She regained her confidence and looked up at us. "Don't get your fur in a bunch." she said. "I'll tell you what happened."
"It was last night." she started explaining. "I was taking my midnight stroll and I spotted a strange-looking-cat woman. I greeted her by saying hi but she didn't answer me. There was a long silence... then she told me to take this potion and all our dreams will come true if I poured it on us. I thought for a moment... then I payed her and took the potion! I went home after that. I looked around the room and started pouring the potion all of us. Finally, I went to bed." Bolt Slash and I looked at one another in confusion and worry. "Why would you buy a random potion from a 'strange-looking-cat woman'?" I asked in disappointment.
There was no response...