Creepypasta x reader(Male) Lemons

Seme reader X Eyeless Jack

Alright, I wanna thank igobypersonorthing for requesting this and being my first comment! Thank you all for reading and I hope you enjoy!

Eyeless Jack's POV

(Y/n) and me have been dating for several months now, but...ALL WE HAVE DONE WAS KISSING AND HOLDING HANDS. Everytime something steamy happens, we stop. He always looks hesitant when we're together... does he even like me? 

A voice interrupted my thoughts, "Hey, ej, you okay?" I look up to see Toby standing near me. He was in his usual get up, Hoodie, goggles, and jeans. He was getting some waffles from the freezer.

"Yeah i'm fine, just a little tired." I replied. I would like to talk to toby, or anyone, about my problems but (Y/n) said that we had to keep our relationship a secret. When I asked why he just said that some of the Pasta's here might not be accepting to a relationship we rarely have, moreso because of our genders. I honestly think its fine, but (y/n) grew up in a backwards place with an accepting and pretty heart. I understand where he is coming from, so as long as he's happy, I'm happy. though I do wish that he would do things with me...or to me... Anyways.

"Alrighty then. B-but..you know...if you ever need someone to talk to..." he placed his hand on mine. I felt him rub my hand slightly, which was weird, but didn't think anything of it. I just smiled and forgot my mask was down, so I just nodded. He left with that and I continued eating my kidneys.

It seems that (Y/n) is back, so that means that we get to spend time together. We normally say hello, and talk later when everyone is asleep, but tonight is special. Tonight, (y/n) is taking me on a date, He's been talking non-stop about how he found this waterfall in the forest. We brought some food and whatnot with us. When we were about to leave though, Toby stopped us. 

"W-where you headed?" He asked, I glanced up at (y/n) and he just slightly nodded. "we are going on a...late night kill..." I said, hoping he would let us leave at that. "ooohhh.... so whats in the bag?" I sighed mentally, I just turned it around and opened it. "just some extra kidneys, in case the kidneys i find are...bad.." I was glad i had a mask because i was making a face that would say 'IM LYING ITS ACTUALLY THINGS LIKE CLOTHES AND CANDLES' I sighed and waved to toby as we left the manor.

"t-that was scary...." I said as I leaned onto (y/n)'s shoulder. "You're in a house full of killers and monsters, and THAT scared you?" He said, as he wrapped his arm around my shoulder. We walked for a while until we reached a tree that had some weird mark on it. "Are we almost there?" I asked as i glanced up at him. He looked down at me and smiled. "we are almost there, don't worry." he said as he pulled me closer to him. I smiled and hugged his arm. We continued for a while, but then I heard waves in the distance. "Is that it?" I face him completely and he just smiled. "Yep! welcome to Ej Falls!" He smiled and boasted. I started laughing "ej..F-falls..." He walked up to me and placed his hand on my cheek. He kissed me slowly and gently, I could hear his heartbeat and it was really relaxing. "I love you.." I said into our kiss. "Me too" He said as he held me close.

Ticci Toby's POV

I followed them into the forest. I thought it was weird that they went out together. 
I saw them get closer to each other. Maybe they are just really close friends? I continued to watch them until they came onto a waterfall. They held each other real close.
"....love..you..." I heard. I felt myself get angry for some reason. Ej...with that guy?....I thought I got rid of all interests for him...why?...how?...it's not fair. What does he have that I don't? I was there for ej, good and bad times. I'll make ej mine. He has to be mine. If he doesn't..then too bad, right?

Ej POV
We came back to the mansion after our little date. I saw Toby and tried to talk to him, but he was mad for some reason.
"Hey ej." Toby said, slightly looking up at me. "Can you meet me later? I have some stuff I wanna discuss with you, you know, like how my cheek is doing and if I have obtained any injuries." He said. I smiled softly, glad that he isn't mad. "Yeah I'll meet you" I said beaming.
He smiled and looked up at me. Something didn't feel right. "Yeah see you" I felt uneasy, but I'm sure it was just me being paranoid.
I met him in his room, per request, and I got my kit out. I removed his mask and started tending to his cheek, when all of a sudden he pushed me down, knocking my tools over and out of my hand. "Mmph!?" He moved my mask and shoved his tongue into my mouth, I tried fighting back, but I some how ended up melting into it. I started to kiss back and he started getting more intimate. He pushed his hand up my shirt and started touching my nipples, making me moan softly. I started to wrap my hands around him.
All of a sudden, the door broke open and (y/n) stared at us. "W-wait this isn't-" toby interrupted me. "He's mine, don't even try to. See how he was accepting me?" He said like he was boasting over an object. I glanced at (y/n)...he was angry. I've never seen him so mad. He was always calm and collected.
He walked up to toby. "..ej...isn't...YOURS" he suddenly punched him in the face, reopening his wound. He grabbed me harshly and took me to his room.
He slammed and locked the door, throwing me on his bed. He walked up to me, not letting me get a word out. He threw my hoodie off and started to roughly make out with me. His tongue swirled in my mouth, reaching every crevice, every inch. His hands traveled up my shirt, squezzing my nipples. I felt a jolt run through my body, his cold hands twisting my chest lightly. His body pushed onto mine as we fell onto his bed, his knees pressing against my groin causing me to groan into the kiss. He chuckled lightly and we continued with the sloppy make out for a while, he stopped for breath which made me make a face that I couldn't describe.
"God your hot.." he took my hoodie off and began to tease my chest. I felt his tongue swirl around my nipple, but he bit it which made me moan like crazy. He looked up at me with wonder and then curiosity. "...maybe..." He started to bite my neck in different places, cause a jolt of pleasure to run through my body. He bit down really hard on one spot which sent me over the edge and caused me to cum in my pants. He smiled as he looked at all the bite marks on me.
"Your beautiful like this. Your beautiful and your mine" his words were possessive, but I didn't seem to mind it like I did with Toby, instead it made me happy. "I'm.....yours?" I said, looking him in the eye. He smiled as he held me. "Of course. I own you. You are mine to touch and love." His hands slinked down to my pants. He yanked them down. "And I'm going to play with you as much as I like" this made me really happy, I was confused and slightly scared, but I felt better knowing it was (y/n). "Okay" I said, then he trailed kisses down my body, all the way until my underwear. "I love these..." He said as he sniffed them, which made me really embarrassed. "D-dont sniff that! That's...that's..." I couldn't finish the sentence because he started to nibble on me down there. "Your so cute...even down here.." he pulled my underwear down with his teeth and started to lick my already hard and sticky cock. "D-dont..mn.." he started to suck me, swirling his tongue around me and jacking off what he couldn't reach. I felt his hand stiffen which almost made me climax again. "Uh-uh naughty boy. Bad boys who cum without permission get punished." He said in a sweet and seductive voice. "P-please let me cum.. I have to, I can feel everything around there." I pleaded. He blew on my penis which made some precum leak out.
"Let's see how long you can handle this.." he said as he grabbed a tube out of a drawer next to him. He opened the bottle and poured the cold liquid onto my penis and ass. I shivered as he rubbed around my ass hole.
"Aren't you excited?~" he purred as he pushed the top of his finger inside me. He slowly pushed in his finger, in and out, in and out. I felt a whole new world of pleasure open up to me, his finger grazing across my prostate. I let out little moans as he pumped another finger. I started getting dazed, and before I realized, I was having 4 fingers inside me.
"You seem ready enough.." he grabbed the lube and rubbed his member with it. He laid me on my back and pushed my legs up. I felt my face become red when I realized what was about to happen. "Wai- wait I'm not rea-dyy!~" he pushed himself inside slowly and I felt myself becoming stretched out. He left himself inside for at least a minute to wait for me. He moved his hips slowly, causing me to moan quietly. He started to pick up the pace. He lifted me up on top of him and started to pound into me. I felt him go deeper and deeper. I was enjoying the feeling when I was hit with a weird jolt of pleasure through my body causing me to moan really loud. When I looked at (Y/n), he smiled as he removed his hand from my leg, showing a red handprint. He had slapped me, and it felt good. I felt myself be confused only to be caught out of thought by another jolt, this time on my other leg. "Your so beautiful.." he pulled out, causing me to whimper. Then he turned me around and pushed my face into the bed. He thrust himself into me hard and continued to thrust harder and faster. He slapped my ass and scratch my back every so often causing me to leak out cum. "Your a bad bad boy, ej~" (y/n) whispered into my ear, biting it hard right after. I felt him twitch slightly, then the word I have been waiting to hear slipped out of his mouth.
"Cum." It was like I was under his control. I felt myself exactly cum at that moment. His warm cum filled me inside.
We both sat there panting. The smell of sweat and cum was very apparent in the room. I felt myself pass out right next to him. "I love you, ej" he whispered to me as I fell asleep.

Okay I'm so sorry this came out late. Please request something below, thanks!