Super Animal Crossing 2 Goodbye Despair

The First Island Trial

Everyone went to the center of the island where they were greeted with a few podiums placed in a circle. There was also a photo of Wilbur present.

"Well to the first ever Deserted Island trial. This is where you all debate on who's the killer. If you guess the killer correctly, the killer will be executed. Allow me to show you an example" Redd said. He pushes a button and a few spears rain from the sky, directly into Sherb. Everyone gasps.

"Relax it's just a dummy" Redd says bringing out the real Sherb, who is terrified.

"However, if you guess incorrectly, I will kill everyone except for the killer. Do I make myself clear?" Redd said. Everyone nodded.

"Alright then, it's time for the first ever island trial," Redd said.

BEGIN TRIAL

"Wilbur…." Orville said. "He was my brother who was always looking out for me since we were kids. He did his best to protect me and he was such a big help around the airport. I don't know what I'm gonna do without him"

"We're so sorry Wilbur. We'll find who did this to him" Katie said. "As far as we know, the killer used some sort of weapon. Like a knife or something"

"NO THAT'S WRONG!" Yu said. "It wasn't a knife, it was a pipe and at the crime scene, Bob discovered a pawprint where Wilbur was laying."

"OF COURSE" Bob said. "It wasn't no ordinary pawprint, it was a cat paw print, along with cat scratches"

"That narrows our choices down to Katie, Bob, Tangy and Kid Cat" Reese said.

"I was with you guys when we were at Retail" Bob said. "I never leave Sherb by himself. You guys know this"

"OF COURSE" Tangy said "I've known Bob and Sherb since we were kids. They are the best of friends. I rarely see those two apart, reeeeOWR"

"I was also at retail," Katie said. "Reese said she needed some help at the shop"

"THAT'S RIGHT!" Reese said. "Katie offered to help me with the shop when everyone else came"

"That leaves up with Tangy and Kid Cat," Yu said.

"HOLD IT" Tangy said. "There was something else at the crime scene besides the prints and the scratch. Wilbur seemed to have given us a clue on who killed him, reeeeOWR" Tangy said. "Did anyone notice the number 1 written in blood?"

There was a silence.

"Who here is associated with the number 1?" Tangy said.

"THAT'S IT" Yu said. 

END TRIAL

"The killer has to be… Kid Cat!" Yu said, pointing. Everyone gasped. Kid Cat looked around nervously.

"Wait-" Kid Cat said.

"And I know exactly how you did it," Yu said.

"The Killer approached Wilbur and scratched him to get his attention. Then he beat him senseless with the pipe. The killer quickly fled the scene, leaving the paw prints on the floor. Before Wilbur died, he was able to write a hint for us in his own blood. Isn't that right Kid Cat, the Ultimate Hero?"

Kid Cat said nothing. Instead he started to cry.

"YES! I KILLED WILBUR. BUT I HAD TO" Kid Cat said in tears. Everyone gasps.

"How dare you kill my brother!" Orville said. "If you weren't about to get executed, I would've killed you for sure"

"I'M SORRY WILBUR" Kid Cat cried.

"Well then. I guess it's time to vote for who you think is the killer" Redd said. The results are 14 votes for Kid Cat and 1 for Tangy.

"You guessed correctly. Kid Cat is the murderer. How much of a simp do you have to be to kill someone to save your girlfriend?" Redd said.

"DIRTY BROTHER KILLER!" Orville yelled.

"Now then I prepared a very special punishment for Kid Cat, the Ultimate Hero" Redd said.

"Wait, what about Agent S? Is she okay" Kid Cat said.

"Let's give it everything we got. It's punishment time!" Redd said. 

"Wait no. I won't believe these lies. Please. AGENT S MY LOOOOVE" Kid Cat cried.