Creepypasta Romance

Cat ears and tail revealed

Toby's p.o.v.

~15 min ago when Celestial was dreaming~
I was tossing and turning since I felt a little off since Jeff was going to be pervy with Cel and that made me soo uncomfortable just thinking what he might do and WHEN he might do it. So me being the gentlemen and all I got up and went to her room. I knocked on her door softly to try and not wake her up,there was no answer, I then decided to go in her room. As I look in the room it looked like a ordinary teenage girl's room, I looked around for a bit, but I then turn to my left to see Cel sleeping so cutely and innocently. Damn she made me blush so hard, I looked at her face and noticed she was scared and terrified. I felt uneven so I go onto her side resting my head and arms on the bed, watching over her so nothing happen to her, but eventually I fell asleep.

~In the morning~
I wake up and I then realized that Cel's right hand was on my left hand which made me blush like hell. I look up at her and smiled and kissed her forehead which made her jump a little, blush, and made her eyes start to open. I then stop get up and exited the room happy that I did that and walked to the living room and watched some TV.

Celestial's p.o.v.
I wake up but my face was on fire for some reason. I was so confused, but I shrugged it off and wonder why I had that dream. I just got up and did my morning routine. I went to the kitchen to get something to eat, but when I got in I saw a little girl about the age of 5 or 7, she also wore a pink nightgown that was covered in dirt, she had cut and bruises, brown hair, green eyes, blood leaking from her forehead, and she had a brown bear that was also dirty. She turned to me and grinned widely, she then said to me "Do u want to play with me?"
I was scared but Slender came and picked up the little girl. "Now Sally don't do that to our newest pasta." "What she's a pasta Slendy?" "Yes she is now apologize to her now." She nodded and looks at me saying "Srry that I scared u miss."
"Its ok I wasn't all that scared." To be honest I was scared as hell. She smiled and said that her name was Sally and after that introduction we spend 5 hours with each other, but she then asked a question that made me jump. "Why do u wear the hood?" "Oh I don't know because I want to?"

"Oh come on don't be shy let me take off ur hood." She jumps down and starts to reach for my hood, but I ran to my room so she won't take my hood off. Sally then knock on my door and I turn into a mouse and ran again, but this time she chased me around the mansion.
~30 mins later~
I hid under the couch as a mouse, still hiding from Sally. All of a sudden someone grabs my tail and picks me up. I struggle to get free, but a familiar calm,soothing and relaxing voice then says "Hey calm down its alright." I turn around to see Toby, I then stop squirming and Sally was right there. I freaked out and squirmed again.
"Sally did u scare her." "Nooooo." "R u sure" "...yes." I then managed to get free I ran to the roof, turned back to my human form with my hood on still and freaked out since I was so conscious with my ears and tail. All of a sudden my hoodie came straight off and I froze stunned at what happened since my ears and tail were exposed.
"Ohhhh ur a kitty cat." Sally yelped so happy and giggly. "Sally" Toby said sternly and angry and Slender was there too. Slender grabbed Sally went downstairs and Toby sat next to me. "Hey Cel it's ok alright and besides I like cats I think their...cool."
He put his hand on my ear and pet them causing me to come back to reality and purring with a faint blush on my face.

Toby's P.O.V.
I blushed when I heard Cel purring. It...kinda...want me to...kiss her. Wait what am I thinking I barely even know her so why in the hell am I thinking about kissing her? I think there's something wrong with me. I then grabbed her hand, rised up so she came up with me, walked downstairs, explain to everyone about her ears and tail, and just had a normal day the rest of the day.
~9:35~
Apparently Slender wants us all to go to bed early right now since we got to train to defeat Zalgo and his disciples and I was a little pissed off, but hey it's his rule now. I was still wrried about Cel tho, but she's seems...fine now I guess. Oh well I'm just glad I get to meet a nice girl that has beautiful eyes and has a wonderful personality because u never see girls like that now a days. I got to my room and get under the covers, close my eyes and fall asleep.