Insanity (Casey Johnson/Jake Sims)

Chapter 5

Casey's view:

I woke up the next morning with Hunter cuddled up to me. I gently took my arm off of her and walked into the kitchen area to get some cereal. I thought I was the only one awake then I heard James's voice behind me."How come you never came to bed last night?" he asked curiously.

"I stayed with Hunter. She was scared," I replied shrugging my shoulders. I was just being nice to her but of course all the boys take it completely the wrong way and think I'm just trying to get at her. I'm really not! She's gorgeous and everything but that's Barclay's sister.

"If Barclay hears about this you're dead, mate," James chuckled slightly. My jaw clenched real fast. If Barclay hears about this he wouldn't even let me be within 10 feet of her.

"If you keep your mouth shut he won't find out," I growled lowly. He put his hands up in defense and walked away leaving me alone to eat my breakfast in peace.

Everyone was finally awake so we all just kind of sat around and hung out. Everything was going great until Reece opened his mouth. "I walked to my bunk last night and saw Casey and Hunter cuddled up. How lucky did you get last night Case?" Reece winked at me. Shit I'm dead.

"What did he just say?! Did you seriously sleep with my little sister after I specifically told you she was off limits?! Oh you're so dead Johnson!" Barclay screamed at me.

"Woah woah woah. Nothing happened between me and Casey. Come on Barclay, you know I wouldn't lie to you," Hunter said calmly stepping in between Barclay and me. I mentally thanked her because in a matter of seconds I could have been slammed to the floor and beaten nearly to death.

"Yeah come on, mate. That's your sister. I would never do that," I found the courage to finally say.

"I never know what you would and wouldn't do," he mumbled more to himself than me.

"What's that supposed to mean?" I asked slightly offended. I know that I'm a massive flirt but that doesn't mean I would sleep with my bandmate's sister.

"Come on Casey. We all know you're the biggest flirt ever," Jake butted in.

"That doesn't mean I would sleep with Hunter! Barclay is one of my best friends. I would never sleep with his sister," I stood up for myself.

"Yeah sure Casey," Jake rolled his eyes. If Hunter asked him to stay with her he would have! He's just mad that I'm closer to her than he is.

"Alright boys let's all just calm down. There was no harm done so let's drop it," Hunter said.

I nodded my head knowing that this conversation was never going to go my way. I sat down on the couch and ran my hands through my hair. Am I really that big of a flirt to the point they all think I would sleep with my friend's sister?

"Okay seriously I know you banged her. Just admit it,' Jake whispered to me. That's what sent me over the edge.

"I never put a sexual hand on her! Damn it I have more respect for her than that! Can't you see that I really didn't do anything? I'm so done with this! I may be flirty but I would NEVER take it this far!" I yelled walking off to my bunk and slamming the door roughly. I'm just a flirt. I'm just a flirt...

 Hunter's view:

"Really guys? You couldn't have just let it be like I said to. Seriously nothing happened between us. You're making him look like a total ass but in reality you're the asses!" I screamed at them. They all had their heads hung low and wouldn't make eye contact with me.

"Well do you have anything to say?" I asked getting impatient with their silence.

"You don't know Casey like we do. He is the biggest flirt in my life and just kind of gets around to girls. Barclay said finally looking at me.

"That doesn't matter if he normally does that. He didn't do that to me so why couldn't you believe him when he told you he didn't?" I asked getting my composure back. They all just shrugged their shoulders, not really knowing what to say.

"I’m gonna go talk to him," I said walking towards Casey's room. I walked in and he was sat on his bed with his hands tearing through his hair.

"Hey calm down. I just yelled at the boys so I think they got the message. Even if they didn't, I'll always know the truth and so will you and that's all that matters," I whispered laying my head on his shoulder.

"But I don't want them to think of me that way,” he whined.

"After what I said to them they won't. They just think you're a big flirt," I said winking and walking out of his room.

Nothing but a massive flirt. Nothing more...

A/N SORRY I HAVEN'T UPDATED IN A WHILE BUT THIS IS THE FIRST DAY SINCE I WENT BACK TO SCHOOL AFTER BREAK THAT I HAVEN'T HAD HOMEWORK. SO HERE'S A PRETTY DECENT UPDATE FOR Y'ALL!

Xx-Taylor