Toby X Reader

497 2 3
                                    

You've always liked the idea of going to Slender's Mansion. You've only ever heard tales about it, how it's haunted and all the Creepypastas will kill you if you come close to it. What's the worst that could happen? You've got nothing to lose.
One evening, you decide to trek into the woods and find Slender's Mansion. It takes a long while. The forest is eerie, and occasionally you hear scraping sounds in the bushes and see them shaking. Maybe it's the Rake.
All of a sudden, you hear distant music, as if a party is going on. You follow the sound and soon find yourself staring at the most elegant house - no, mansion - you've ever seen. Flashing lights are seen from outside it and silhouettes are dancing, everyone's bodies colliding in the shadows.
Why not knock on the door? Let them know you're not a threat. You've also heard stories that if you don't want to be killed by them, you have to knock three times, no more and no less.
So that's what you do. Suddenly, the music stops, the silhouettes have frozen and there is a hushing sound from a few people.
The huge door opens a tiny crack. "Who is it?" someone says rather quietly.
"Um, I'm y/n. I've just come to, uh, party, I guess", you reply with a shrug.
"Well, come on in then!" the voice booms happily. The door is now fully open and welcoming you. There are a large number of people staring at you as you slowly make your way into the hall with streamers and confetti lying around. They all look exactly as you had imagined. Frankly, your favourite just had to be Ticci Toby. There was something about him that sort of made you want to talk to him. As soon as you're inside the house, your eyes scan the sea of killers and you finally find those round orange goggles. You grin to yourself. You have to go talk to him.
Soon you find him also staring at you. You quickly turn away and begin talking to Slender man.
"Hello, child. What brings you here?"
"I thought this place would be really cool, and I love the Creepypastas", you reply. Toby's eyes are still trained on you, carefully watching your every move.
"Okay everyone! 7 Minutes in Heaven!!!" Splendorman announces loudly.
Everyone sits in a circle and places an object in that hat. Oh, that fucking hat. You've heard all about it. Soon you find it right up in your face. "Okay, choose one", Splendor grins.
You shove your hand in quite hard, and feel a blade. You prick your finger, and curse Jeff. He must know you found it, and his grin gets even bigger. You search around more, and feel something soft. You pick it out.
A handkerchief for glasses of some sort. It's soon snatched out of your hand and you are led to the fucking closet by Splendorman.
The door locks behind you.
"Who did I get?" you say smugly, trying to hide your fear.
"Me", he replies, smashing his lips into yours. He grabs your waist and pulls you closer to him, feeling up and down your body.
Fucking Toby.
You smile to yourself, knowing that this will be fun. He pulls away, panting quite loudly. "So, y/n. I've had my eyes on you since you walked into this party. I think you're pretty sexy", he purrs into your ear. You chuckle at his words.
"You're not too shabby yourself." You smirk up at him.
"2 minutes gone, guys", someone yells from outside.
You feel something quite sharp poke your thigh, and soon realize that it's Toby's erection. You giggle.
He reaches under your shirt and gropes your breast with one hand, while his other caresses your cheek. Soon his other hand is under your shirt, and he's unclipping your bra strap in a flash. Your shirt slips off along with it and Toby smirks at your cleavage.
He seems turned on, you think.
His hand slips down your pants and rubs your clit. You moan, louder than you intended to, and soon hear wolf whistles from the outside. Toby chuckles darkly. His hand stays down there, occasionally shoving a finger or two inside you, making you moan and hearing more perverted whistles from the other side. Jeff even yells "Get it, Toby!"
Every now and then, you see and feel Toby twitching hysterically.
You reach down his boxers and feel his hardened member and rub it in your hands. You both moan simultaneously to each other's touch. He flicks your clit and puts three fingers inside you, and you feel them moving around slowly, discovering their new territory.
He licks your bottom lip, asking for an entrance, which you playfully deny. He growls in your ear and pinches your butt, making you gasp. He takes this as an opportunity to slip his tongue into your mouth and let it roam around. You bite his bottom lip, making him bite yours back.
"...3, 2 , 1!"
The closet doors swing open with a thud, revealing you and Toby, both of you half naked. You squeal and thrust your body around so no one can see you. They burst out laughing, and Toby picks up his shirt from the floor and hands it to you. "Here, put this on", he says softy.
You both make your way out of the closet, your face bright pink with embarrassment, Toby just looking proud.
The rest of your night consists of you two lying on Toby's bed, laughing and joking around.

Oh my god I'm so sorry this is terrible and very short and I'm shit at writing stories so pls pls pls don't hate me even if you read this ily ~~~

Creepypasta 7 Minutes in HeavenWhere stories live. Discover now