Creepypasta x reader lemons ;)

Jeff the Killer & Ben DROWNED

You heard a knock on your door, "Took him long enough" you said to yourself. You wanted to talk to Jeff, he had spread rumors about you and Ben being together. It really pissed you off, and you wanted it to stop.

You got up from your chair and walked up to the door, opening it. "Oh JESUS CHRIST PUT ON SOME DAMN CLOTHES!" You screamed at Jeff, he was wet and only in a towel

"You're the one who wanted to talk to me." Jeff answered, "Now you got the chance." You gave him an annoyed look, "At least put on some pants." You told him. "If my beautiful body bothers you that much, fine" Jeff said, but had a smirk on his damn face. "But what?" You questioned him, knowing that wasn't the end of it. "You gotta join." He finished, "Because?" you questioned, "You're the one who wants me to." Jeff said, getting a shit-eating grin, "If you don't join, I won't do it"

*He got such a fucking good point though* You thought to yourself. "Fine, but only so that you'll at least wear some damn pants." You finally answered. "Alright." Jeff said, grabbing your hand, leading you out from your room. You closed the door behind you, and followed right behind Jeff to his own room.

Jeff suddenly stopped in front of you, making you pump into him. You walked up next to him and waited for him to open the door. After a few seconds, "What are you waiting for?" Jeff asked you, "I'm waiting for you to open the damn door." you answered him. "Why should I open it for you?" Jeff asked, giving you a cocky smirk. "Do I really have to open it for you?" You asked him, knowing he wanted you to do it for him.

"Pretty much," Jeff answered. *At least he's honest about it.* You thought to yourself while twisting the handle, causing the door to open. "Now go and get a pair of fucking pants" You ordered him, pushing him inside, then walking in yourself and closed the door. Jeff turned around and gave you a pissed off look, "I don't want to see you almost bare-ass naked while talking about the rumors you keep spreading!" You yelled at him as an answer.

Jeff was not happy, "You don't ever, EVER, push me into my own fucking room!" he yelled back at you, making you slightly jump. He walked up to you, causing you to take a step back, hitting the door with you back. Jeff smirked as you gulped.

"Look who's in control now" Jeff smirked, holding your wrists up in a tight grip. He took a few steps back himself, dragging you with him. He walked up to the wall next to the bed, then slammed your back into the wall making you groan out in pain. This was the point where you got scared, you knew he was planning something terrible.

His face got closer to yours, giving you a shiver down your spine, feeling his breath tickle against your skin. Jeff was about to kiss you, when suddenly the door slammed open. Out of shock, you automatically held Jeffs big and rough hands while looking towards the now open door. You saw someone standing there, short yet taller than you.

You looked closer, struggling to see who's standing there. Jeff's room had a very dark, yet dim light while the hallway light was bright and intense, making it difficult to see who it was standing there.

"I thought we had a deal JEFF!" You heard the person yell at Jeff, it was Ben's voice. *So Ben's the one standing there.* You thought to yourself. "Wait, what deal?" You asked, looking pissed at Jeff. "I'm gonna share with you, geez." You heard him say to Ben. "Calm your tits" Jeff said as Ben closed and locked Jeffs door. "Wait, what the fuck do you mean share with him?" You asked, slowly getting more and more worried, "Share what to be exact?".

Jeff let go of your right hand and walked up to the center of the room. Ben grabbed your right hand with his, "We're gonna share you." he said seductively in your ear, making you shudder. "Out of everyone you had options to choose from, why the fuck is it me?" You asked, already getting tired of their shit. "Well, you're an outsider compared to the others." Jeff said in your other ear, "You caught our attention." he finished.