Select All
  • 𝐓𝐢𝐜𝐜𝐢 𝐓𝐨𝐛𝐲 𝐱 𝐑𝐞𝐚𝐝𝐞𝐫: 𝐀𝐧 𝐄𝐲𝐞 𝐅𝐨𝐫 𝐀𝐧 𝐄𝐲𝐞
    20K 556 17

    "Toby believes it's something greater that coerced his mind any time he became violent. It was not his own will to kill but someone else's order infiltrating his intellect." Toby has been on the run for a couple years after he murdered his father and lit up his childhood home, evading not only the law, but Slenderman...

    Completed  
  • Worthless - Jeff the killer x fem reader
    182K 5K 36

    Kidnaped at 12 I'v lived at slender mansion for four years now. I work and maintain the grounds during the days while the creepypasta sleep. Ingrained in my head over the years: "I (Y/N) am worthless"

    Completed  
  • Jeff the killer x shy reader
    113K 2.4K 8

    You are a shy high school girl. You meets a killer * coughs * Jeff the killer Will you learn to love this killer? Will you forgive him ? Will he love you back ? Read to find out

    Completed  
  • Normal // A Ticci Toby x Reader Story
    978K 30.5K 40

    Ehhhhh I'll write a description later

  • Chains (Jeff The Killer X Reader)
    368K 13.4K 30

    Fate can be.. twisted. Sometimes to the point where it's too messed up to fix it. But what if.. what if it isn't so bad after all? "The more blood on my hands, the more my sanity slipped away..." ⚠️I DO NOT OWN THE ARTWORK FOR THIS STORY⚠️ ⚠️Slight profanity, bleeped out, though⚠️ ❗️I update throughout the entire week...

    Completed   Mature
  • 𝓤𝓷𝓮𝔁𝓹𝓮𝓬𝓽𝓮𝓭 𝓒𝓸𝓷𝓷𝓮𝓬𝓽𝓲𝓸𝓷 ~ Jeff the Killer X Reader
    118K 3.1K 40

    Y/N= your name, thoughts are italics in ** Enjoy! You were an ordinary teenage girl. School, bullies, friends, tests and family problems. But the one thing that made you and your best friend Sarah stand out from most other girls at your school... was your love for Creepypasta stories. How will your first day back at...

    Completed   Mature
  • shut up and sleep with me( Jeff the killer x reader )
    181K 3.9K 22

    the title says it all

  • That Smiling Idiot (Jeff the killer x reader)
    484K 14.7K 62

    Y/n is a popular serial killer with the catch phrase 'close your eyes and say goodbye', when she take the throne of most popular serial killer Jeff hunts her down. Will their rivalry turn into love? Or will they continue to try and kill each other? Highest ranks I've ever been: #1 creepypasta #1 jeffthekillerxreader...

  • Freak Show (Jeff the Killer X reader) Book 1
    193K 7.8K 24

    *Book 1* Living in a Freak Show is like living in hell, but can a Joker wannabe change it all?

    Completed   Mature
  • My Beautiful Nightmare Book 2
    93.5K 4K 24

    *Book 2 of the Freak Show* Jeff the killer x reader

    Completed  
  • Make You Beautiful - [Jeff the Killer x reader]
    512K 16.7K 41

    [COMPLETED] "There's something I just have to do. Remember that incident with BEN?" I frowned and slowly nodded my head. "Well, I need to make sure something like that never happens. I need to make sure that everyone knows that you're mine." He smirked and took a knife that was on a night table next to the bed. "Ho...

    Completed   Mature
  • To Live without Fear [Jeff the KillerxReader]
    1M 40.5K 28

    The one thing every living creature has in common is fear. Fear keeps us alive, drives us forward, and makes us still. Jeff the Killer thought he knew everything about fear. He was an artisan, and fear was his craft. Until the day he met the girl who didn't feel fear at all. COVER ART BY KAWACY ON DEVIANTART

  • Two Murderers (Jeff the Killer x Reader)
    266K 6K 63

    **//CURRENTLY UNDER REVISION, FIRST CHAPTERS MAY NOT LINE UP WITH THE REST OF THE STORY\\** **(Screw it. I'm writing a whole ass new version of this. I can't rewrite every chapter here. This is gonna be funnnnn. Am still keeping this version up for those who wanna continue to read this cringe mess. tysm yall for stic...

    Mature
  • Jeff the killer x reader
    154K 3.5K 66

    y/n was a not a normal girl. she would always get beaten by her father because he would always get drunk. one night she heard a big crash downstairs. what will happen next?

    Completed   Mature
  • My Beloved Killer (Jeff The Killer fanfiction)
    259K 7.8K 27

    Jasmine Price is a 17 year old girl, who lives in Denver, with her abusive parents. Jasmine only has two friends Cam and Rose. She goes through life everyday being bullied at school and at home. Jasmine meets Jeff the killer and wonders can she love a killer?

  • My bloody Romance (Jeff the killer x reader) [DISCONTINUED]
    135K 4.2K 25

    Your name is (Y/N) (L/N). Your father has gotten a job at some far away place he refuses to tell you the name of and says you suddenly have to move. You're forced to leave your life behind and all the memories with it, leaving your friends who you considered family and leaving the house you have lived in for pretty mu...

  • I Found You {Jeff The Killer X Reader}
    294K 8.5K 17

    『 #8 ɪɴ ᴊᴇғғ ᴛʜᴇ ᴋɪʟʟᴇʀ 』 The blood rushed over my body, heart beating, world spinning. It was a whole new world, I never knew something so bad could feel so good. The blood on my hands, the scream of their voices- I've done it. I've killed my first victims. This was the first murder in 2 years in our small town since...

    Completed  
  • The Innocent Eyes (Jeff The Killer X Reader)
    510K 11.3K 69

    *100,888 words* Strange things happen under strange circumstances and sometimes the most unsafe people make you feel the most safe. When you meet Jeff, he's not exactly like the stories you've heard. Perhaps he's just broken, but aren't we all? Can you fix each other? Will he finally be able to love something, despite...

    Completed   Mature
  • Killer Love (Jeff The Killer x Reader)
    453K 11.4K 50

    Your life takes a drastic turn when you meet him, no i'm not talking about prince charming, quite the opposite actually. Highest Ranking: #1 in JeffTheKiller

    Completed  
  • Smile (Jeff the killer X Reader)
    369K 8.9K 19

    A love story between two twisted hearts. As your world falls apart you meet the famous serial killer Jeff. What will happen? *Warning: contains violence and lemon*

    Completed   Mature
  • Mad House (Jeff the Killer X reader)
    774K 24.8K 28

    Jeff the killer x reader Is it possible for you to fall in love with an insane killer?

    Completed   Mature
  • The Game [Jeff The Killer x Reader]
    430K 17.2K 37

    I wasn't sure what love was. Everyone spoke of it like a legend. Something sacred that you'd capture if you were lucky. The man I had let take my heart wanted to carve it out of my chest as proof. I tried to forget feeling that way about him. I tried to figure out why I could ever love someone like him. He terrified m...

    Completed   Mature
  • Jeff The Killer x Reader
    879K 24.5K 29

    Completed  
  • You're mine || Jeff the killer x Reader ||
    357K 5.6K 10

    What the title says

    Completed  
  • You're a Sharp One (Jeff the Killer X Female! Killer! Reader)
    316K 7.5K 25

    "Now now.." Jeff's gruff voice whispered into your ear as he pinned you against the wall of your bedroom walls with his knife pressed against your neck. "You're always complaining how no one can catch you, but, you seem so frightened, with my knife against your [skin toned] neck. Face it. You're destined to death," he...

    Completed  
  • Jeff The Killer X Reader
    3.3M 117K 62

    Secrets. Some are best hidden from the world and from other people. Although, the more secrets that build up, the angrier a person may get.

    Completed  
  • Fugitive (Jeff The Killer x Reader)
    341K 9.6K 53

    When a new kid named Jeff moved to (y/n)'s hometown and attended the same school as her, the two of them were instantly best friends. Other people would even think they were a 'thing'. Until he went insane and killed his family. Three years had passed since that tragic night and now it was summer vacation, but this su...

    Completed   Mature
  • Blue Love | Sally Face x Reader
    666K 18.2K 47

    ~Please read the entire description~ After months of struggling, your parents finally managed to get a job as nighttime security for a mall in Nockfell. This meant that you'd have to move from your childhood home into some apartment complex that you've never heard of before. You should be happy for them, but you can't...

  • ★Sally Face x Reader Oneshots★
    486K 6.5K 38

    Ay You know what it is smut, fluff, loaf, all that gud stuff and it all of the characters and you E n j o y {{REQUEST CLOSED FOR GOOD}} ALL SALLY FACE CHARACTERS BELONG TO PORTABLEMOOSE/STEVE GABRY

    Completed   Mature