Select All
  • When The Light Touches The Sky (Eyeless jack x reader)
    135K 4.1K 39

    (Y/n) lived with her "Guardian " since she was five and she was given up by her real parents so she loved her new caregiver, Chris. Chris and (Y/N) loved creepy things and conspiracies. Now what if Chris goes to the edge of the line. ⚠important ⚠ May include: -Triggering moments -Crying -Author not posting because...

  • Chains: Eyeless Jack X Reader
    3.7M 139K 57

    I didn't write this but I have been given permission to post this all credit goes to Valentinesdaygreen and a link below to the original story origin http://valentinesdaygreen.deviantart.com/

    Completed  
  • Eyeless Jack x Ticci Toby
    40.3K 981 24

    He killed his dad, found a new home, finally settled in, even made some new friends. What else? Oh yeah, and watched his crush get brutally murdered and sacrificed by a cult.

    Completed  
  • Masky x Child reader
    100K 2K 15

    You are the daughter of Masky aka (I'm giving him a made up name ok?) Brandon Matthews. He married a woman named (Mom's name). One day your mother had enough of the secrets and ran away from Brandon and toke you away with her. She now married a new man that goes by name of Peter Reyes. He is a person who has lots of...

    Completed  
  • The New And The Silent
    47.8K 1.4K 27

    ⚠️Not my art, I just edited them together! Toby art by- Lynnarty | EyelessJack art by- LilJay14 ⚠️ Toby is the new kid in the mansion, and he's immediately interested in the silent, blue masked man that walks through the mansions halls. (That's such a tacky description- I'm sorry T^T)

  • I Think I Love You
    53.3K 1.3K 12

    From burning his house down, to being taken in by a faceless eldritch creature. Toby has now become curious about a certain mask wearing man. He knows just the way to get closer to him, but he realizes this might be more than he bargained for. Warning for: Gore, medical descriptions/situations, and slight homophobia...

  • Glass Breaks Too Easily. (Eyeless Jack x Reader Book 2)
    5.3K 278 17

    Peace was never something I had known, and not something I was comfortable in getting to know. To say that I had grown accustomed to not only living in fear but thriving in that exact way of life would be a huge understatement; at this point, it wouldn't even be going too far as to say I enjoyed living in fear. If liv...

  • What Lovely Kidneys You Have (An Eyeless Jack P.O.V & Romance)
    29.7K 1.3K 25

    "A kiss is the beginning of cannibalism." - Georges Bataille. Jack has a, special, type of appetite; he devours kidneys. His twisted diet demands for victims, scalpels, and malevolent intuition. Stalking his prey for days on end, patience and precision is a virtue for ripping the unwilling donors apart, just before he...

    Completed  
  • A Myth (Doma x reader)
    10.2K 248 10

    (Doma x Reader) ___ Our lovely (Y/N) decides to explore the abandoned temple of the Eternal Paradise Faith, which was a cult that had worshiped someone who apparently had the ability to talk to the gods. What will she find..? What will she come across..? And possibly, will she meet anyone..? "My, my, what do we have h...

    Mature
  • Glass Eye (Eyeless Jack X Reader)
    152K 5.5K 53

    Breaking news is typically a term used to accentuate the severity of a set situation or event; socially, the term 'Breaking News' has become a sort of slang term in conversation to mean ' I have something important to tell you.' It was a phrase commonly heard, commonly spoke, and commonly disregarded. She really hoped...

    Completed  
  • [L¤ve Triangle¤] Proxies x reader
    128K 2.6K 36

    You meet a tall man in the woods, helps you and soon you were going to be a proxy but you had 3 teammates. Toby , hoodie and masky. They liked you every since you first came, but they weren't the only ones that did. Jeff, Ej , sonic, Lj and Ben also liked you. Technically a Love Octagon hehe. You then had a brot...

  • Just empty eye sockets: Eyeless Jack x Reader *completed*
    985K 28.5K 41

    Someone has recently been leaving notes in your room. Who is your stalker, and why are they stalking you? Is it safe to write back?

    Completed  
  • Letters To You // Eyeless Jack x Reader
    503K 20.9K 57

    She always wanted to write letters to strangers. She wanted them to be old fashioned, like those messages in bottles or the ones written with inked quills. The anonymity of it all seemed so delightful, the girl would tell them her stories and they would do the same in return. They'd never meet and hear each other's vo...

    Completed  
  • Mom! I'm Texting Serial Killers! (Creepypasta x reader)
    645K 17.8K 40

    Highest rankings: #1 on creepypastaxreader #1 on creepypasta When Y/N L/N accidentally gets added onto a groupchat of absolute imbeciles, she, an idiot, decides to continue to talk to these "angsty teens". Unbeknownst to her, they kinda do be killing doe. 😳👀 This is inspired by many texting fanfics I've read! I fo...

  • Eyeless Jack x Reader
    282K 7.3K 14

    Eyeless Jack, has recently taken a liking to someone. That just happens to be you. This is my first fanfic, the first chapter would be the worst (Coming from me, as in the writer), but hey give it a shot.

    Completed  
  • Eyeless, But Never Heartless (Eyeless Jack X Reader)
    163K 4.7K 22

    Abusive father, dead mother. Who will save you? Why, the one and only Eyeless Jack, of course! But being forced to move doesn't sound like a hero move, does it? Maybe you'll fall for your captor, and maybe the eyeless killer isn't heartless after all... This story is written by Catastrophe

    Completed