What if the pogues were originally a group of 5, but one of them mysteriously died when they were 15. After John B and Sarah escape the island and find their way to Nassau they meet up with an old friend who will help them on their journey to get back and clear John B's name. Logan Pierce, the fifth member of the pog...
Y/N is a pogue, and best friends with JJ, but she's had feelings for him for a while.
NOTE: This story is about the pogues, JJ and y/n story before the events of the OBX series happened. Y/N and JJ always had a connection and were really close. But could their relationship be more than that? But you know the rule "No pogue on pogue Mackin".