CreepyPasta boyfriend Scenarios! -COMPLETED-

Just some scenarios :D 1M READS 10/4/2017 HIGHEST RANK- #31 FANFICTION, #96 IN CREEPYPASTA, AND #3 IN CREEPYPASTAROMANCE!! I COULDNT HAVE DONE THIS WITHOUT ALL YOU LOVELY PEOPLE!! :D

Too quiet... Jeff The Killer X Ben drowned

Jeff used to be quite a happy and loud person, but he suddenly becomes a quiet shut in killer. He thought that he was stupid for liking another guy. But only Ben seemed to notice the difference in Jeff. Is Jeff alright? Will ben like Jeff back?

Jeff The Killer x Reader

Creepypasta Zodiacs ✔️

Oh look...another Creepypasta Zodiac Book... Sigh.