#1
The Switchby Erica here 
1.3K
36
4
1.3K364What happens when cooper and gage switch lives!? A lot of confusion!!!!
#2
The Sister In Law (a shaytards fan...by Cassidy Eastland3K754
3K754This is a story about Shay Carl falling in love with his sister in law, Kayli, after she kisses him right before moving to Idaho. Shay begins to question if he married t...
#3
Giving Her Away: A Shaytards FanFicby butlerclanfan5821
5821What would have happened if Colette and Shay got married 2 years earlier and had a girl named Ashlyn Carlie in April of 2002. Read to find out what happens at Carlie's w...
#5
Butlers grown upby vanypie15164.9K12524
4.9K12524The shaytards have all grown up
Gavin is 30
Avia is 28
Emmi is 26
Brock is 23
And Daxton is 19
The whole family has all changed everyone has more kids and they are all v...
#8
Not the one?!?!by vanypie15161.3K366
1.3K366What went wrong? what happens when Colette realizes that she married the wrong butler brother? That the one she is really meant to be with is Casey? And what happens whe...
#9
The New Additionby shaytardsrock417151
417151Emmi's pov: it's the last day of school I can't wait our teacher says we are having a surprise visitor I wonder who it is
Colette's pov: shay I don't feel to good I'm g...