Creepypastayaoi Stories

42 Stories

It Isn't Just Guilt by BeachedNarwhal
#1
It Isn't Just Guiltby Kenny
Tim and Toby are two of Slenders best proxies. Yet they're both complete opposites, well, only with the things they like. One hassling and mothering the other while one...
JeffXToby Creepypasta Yaoi by DeanAndVanilleBons
#2
JeffXToby Creepypasta Yaoiby Dean love Waffles
Toby lived awhile now in the Creepypasta mansion and it would be okay if Jeff wouldn't be there. First Jeff just messed around with Toby but then he definitely gone too...
"My Prince~" little!Ben x Jeff Oneshot Book(Requests Open??) by BennyBoiDrowned
#3
"My Prince~" little!Ben x Jeff One...by Ben
A Ben x Jeff oneshot(one- shot? One shot?) book. fight me, I dare you. This is a Ben x Jeff book where Ben is actually a little. whoah, what a surprise, hUh? ( Can you t...
Kill me the moment I say I love you ( Jeff the killer X Ben Drowned ) by NaomiXHibari
#4
Kill me the moment I say I love yo...by 《 Zal Zal 》
"You two are to share a room for a month!" Slenderman just said to both of us,before leaving just after Jeff and I have a food fight. Jeff X Ben Or in other wo...
I don't need your help by Tushiro
#6
I don't need your helpby Swinging My Soul To Electro S...
a short Zalgo x Slenderman fanfic! enjoy! -UPDATE: PEOPLE WANT ME TO DO MORE THEN I'LL DO MORE DAMN IT-
Ben and Jeff the killer learn what love is /a crappypasta fic by pxkachu
#7
Ben and Jeff the killer learn what...by pxkachu
Jeff is your average white boy /tall?/ white, a murder, and of corse gay as a mofo after killing his parents and giving his lil bromo a scar for lives he got bored with...
Jeff the killer x lui by Sunflower_Girl123
#8
Jeff the killer x luiby Sunflower🌻Girl
hmmm my first time making creepypasta yaoi >w<
×♪Jeff x Ben one-shots♪× by 69Benji_is_high69
#9
×♪Jeff x Ben one-shots♪×by That John Doe simp
(This is my first book. So just to know.. I'm not a good writer. Just started with writing, so.. yep I'm not from any English speaking country, so my English isn't that...
Don't Help Me -- BENxJeff (OneShot) by GrinnyCat
#10
Don't Help Me -- BENxJeff (OneShot)by GrinnyCat
A sad story about BEN's struggle through his current life, and how he just can't take it anymore. This is a BENxJeff, not much of yaoi but the thought of their love exis...
Jeff X Ben (Yaoi) Love Story by ElizabethHoffmann0
#11
Jeff X Ben (Yaoi) Love Storyby ElizabethHoffmann0
UPDATE: I ADDED A BEGINNING TO CHAPTER 1, I BELIEVE IT THEN MADE CHAPTER ONE 3 PAGES! you're welcome ;) ~ ANYWHO~ i won't be updating this for a while because I'm workin...
Addict (Masky x Skully x Hoodie) by theblackmailruler
#12
Addict (Masky x Skully x Hoodie)by Harmony Mojo (Rose Mindset)
(Picture made by darkstarsart on instagram! Thank you for letting you use your pic!) Mostly the same universe as my Jack X Toby book Monsterous Trust, but instead of bei...
Pairing Sentences by ButlerSoulEater
#13
Pairing Sentencesby Yuki Kurosaki
SHIPS IN ONE SENTENCE or more
Creepypasta Yaoi by ErmagherdGirl141
#14
Creepypasta Yaoiby ErmagherdGirl141
If you don't like it, don't read it. I accept requests.
i love you ❤ (ticci toby x masky ) by sofarjustme
#15
i love you ❤ (ticci toby x masky )by just me
a boy that twitches and a boy with a mask what better couple could this be? read to find out . this is my first wattpad story I always get really excited and don't worr...