Jeffxtoby Stories

Refine by tag:

15 Stories

my Shorty jeff x toby smut by WolfyWolves3
#1
my Shorty jeff x toby smutby 💫🖤leo🖤💫
⚠️warning⚠️ smut fluff gay boyxboy Crossovers Dsmp will be in here
Panther and Selenium's Worker *Rewrite* by May304
#2
Panther and Selenium's Worker *Rew...by May
Tobias Erin Rogers has a younger twin sister. Who knew that Toby had another sister besides Lyra Rogers. She's a mystery waiting to be discovered. Will these two get alo...
Completed
Knives and Axes. by CocaAoa
#3
Knives and Axes.by Coca Aoa
Ticci Toby and Jeff are dating, yet..Something is wrong. In the Slender manner a problem erupts. And it involves smile dog.
Jeff    X Toby REDO !! by Cweepypastalife1
#4
Jeff X Toby REDO !!by Gay stuff
Practically a much better and more detailed version of my original Jeff X Toby
Clockwork (JeffxToby) by BUTISHIPIT
#5
Clockwork (JeffxToby)by BUTISHIPIT
JEFF THE KILLER X TICCI TOBY *Trigger warning* This is shit i randomly think of... But anywhore! Heres a super fucking depressing oneshot that I wrote... Read if you wa...
An Odd Love- Jeff x Toby by 0CrayonMilk0
#7
An Odd Love- Jeff x Tobyby Gay With A Headache
Jeff was glad to not have a roommate like most Pastas, and it's as good as it can get for a killer who works for one of the most feared beings to ever exist........ unti...
Jeff x Toby one shot by Living-Dead-Enaid
#8
Jeff x Toby one shotby Living-Dead-Enaid
random one shot because I ship it.
Completed
Normal catboys scare me>_< by xxgoth_nekoxx
#9
Normal catboys scare me>_<by 🖤Willow🖤
Toby Rodgers didn't choose this. He didn't choose to be a smol cat boy. He was picked on all his life for being a neko so he took refuse in his place of work a maid cafe...
Jeff x Toby,  your only mine~  by cweepypastalife
#10
Jeff x Toby, your only mine~ by cweepypastalife
Jeff and Toby have some hard times but they always figure out how to fix the mood
JeffXToby Creepypasta Yaoi by DeanAndVanilleBons
#11
JeffXToby Creepypasta Yaoiby Dean love Waffles
Toby lived awhile now in the Creepypasta mansion and it would be okay if Jeff wouldn't be there. First Jeff just messed around with Toby but then he definitely gone too...
TobyxJeff by Cweepypastalife1
#12
TobyxJeffby Gay stuff
This is my first time making a novel so please dont hate on it I tried my best here.