Missing Puzzle Pieceby Justice31566At the age of 16, you receive a puzzle piece that belongs to your soulmate. You then receive a black mark somewhere on your body to match the piece your soulmate receive...Completedlaughingjasonthetoymakersoulmateau+4 more creepypasta fanfic shortsby Ace6631the title says it alltobyxmaskyhoodiexejljxjason+3 more