Lucas Anderson has been living a normal life ever since last year. He's got a girlfriend now and multiple friends of his own. He's appears to be fine but something has been bothering him on the inside. Lucas thinks he has an idea on who is behind his worrying but he tries to act like everyhting is fine. He decides to ask his girlfriend, Maddy, to prom and with Tyler and a new friend, Jessica. Maddy doesn't show up to prom and Lucas knows that something isn't right. Ms. Charlotte is back but this time she isn't alone. Lucas goes off to look for Maddy with some back-up of his own. Does he save the day once again or do things not work out as planned?