Natalie Diaz just can't catch a break. Not only has Lucas Fell; her best friend, next-door neighbour, and golden boy extraordinaire rejected the feelings she's been harbouring for him since the beginning of time; he's also dating one of her best friends. Deciding that she'd over pined for Lucas, Natalie signs herself up for a baking competition with a grand prize of an all-expenses-paid trip to Paris. Unknown to the fact she needed a partner to complete with, Natalie is surprised when she turns to the last person she'd ever ask for help; Dylan. Unable to bake or see eye-to-eye after the fall fair disaster, Natalie and Dylan are unable to even bake a boxed cake. However, when the sugar and spice really begin to collide there's an unexpected reaction that leads to hearts coming together in the most heartstring pulling manner. Finally, when things are going according to Natalie, Lucas drops a major love bomb on her, leaving her at a crossroad between what matters most to her. It's up to Natalie to hold on to decide between her friendship with Lucas, a budding romance, or the Glendale Bake-Off grand prize. Stakes are high and so are the risks of heartbreak.