16-year-old Noelle Forbes is obsessed with Dylan Drake, a fictional character in Theresa Beckett's popular series "The Silver Stones". She spends most of her time writing fan fiction about her favorite wizard, attending meetings for other fans of "The Silver Stones" series at the local bookstore, and even dressing as Dylan for Halloween. In fact, she has obsessively written Dylan Drake fan fiction to the point of her shutting out other books and even failing English class. But when she receives an "F" on an assignment and is cast as an angel in a Christmas play at the local church, Noelle realizes that her obsession with Dylan Drake is costing her valuable learning time and friendships. Can she kick her obsession to the curb?