maybe unpopular opinion: i LOVE the first tigerstar. i think he was a great villain and his death was chilling. I hate the second Tigerstar tho. I only just finished Sky of A starless clan but Tigerstar II SUCKS. "I don't wanna be like the first!11!!" Mfo you just attacked Riverclan and LITERALLY FORCED THEM to accept your "help" and almost killed a few of them.
"this isn't a takeover, we're helping!" As he commands nearly his entire clan to surround whats left of riverclan as if they're prisoners