So I’ve decided to make a My Babysitters a Vampire story for Ethan because there are just so few out there. I want another opinion on the main character. My first thought was Olivia Holt. Her character is supposed to be really popular, talented, loved, and downright gorgeous. Obviously she fits the bill. But there’s also Madelaine Petsch. She would also fit really well, particularly because she works with Vanessa Morgan (Sarah’s actress) on Riverdale. But I feel like Ethan wouldn’t get close to a girl as intimidating as Madelaine tends to look. Opinions?