Bakeku67

это сообщение может быть оскорбительным 
I just had the WiLdESt revelation from the most unlikely place.
          	
          	What if the AK isn't an unforgivable because it kills you. What if its unforgivable because of HOW it kills you?
          	
          	Maybe I'm barking up a dead tree, but bear with me.
          	Voldes has Horcruxes. All we really know that means is he can't perma die.
          	But when the killing curse hit him, with Horcruxes to spare, he became detached. A wondering soul/ghost/spirit/thing. Without Horcruxes, he just died.
          	
          	So what if AK doesn't 'kill' per say, but detaches your soul from your body? And that's why it's unforgivable. 
          	Cause by all other accounts, they have waaaaay worse ways of offering someone, why would a seemingly peaceful and dare I say, humane way to kill someone painlessly be so hated? Because its actually what they consider the worst sort of Dark Magic; that which mutilated the soul.
          	
          	As I said, maybe I'm wrong or smthn, was just a thought.

Hua_Cheng02

That’s a crazy revelation to have, really cool to think about
• Ответить

25pickleflvrpopcorn

That actually makes sense and is a really cool theory
• Ответить

Bakeku67

это сообщение может быть оскорбительным 
I just had the WiLdESt revelation from the most unlikely place.
          
          What if the AK isn't an unforgivable because it kills you. What if its unforgivable because of HOW it kills you?
          
          Maybe I'm barking up a dead tree, but bear with me.
          Voldes has Horcruxes. All we really know that means is he can't perma die.
          But when the killing curse hit him, with Horcruxes to spare, he became detached. A wondering soul/ghost/spirit/thing. Without Horcruxes, he just died.
          
          So what if AK doesn't 'kill' per say, but detaches your soul from your body? And that's why it's unforgivable. 
          Cause by all other accounts, they have waaaaay worse ways of offering someone, why would a seemingly peaceful and dare I say, humane way to kill someone painlessly be so hated? Because its actually what they consider the worst sort of Dark Magic; that which mutilated the soul.
          
          As I said, maybe I'm wrong or smthn, was just a thought.

Hua_Cheng02

That’s a crazy revelation to have, really cool to think about
• Ответить

25pickleflvrpopcorn

That actually makes sense and is a really cool theory
• Ответить

Bakeku67

I feel so dumb rn guys,
          I just realized, in the seventh book, in Potterwatch, Lee was called River, because his name is Jordan!
          He is the River Jordan.
          I feel so stupid

MeEqualsBookWorm

@Bakeku67 OH I REMEMBER THA— yeah crap no I genuinely never thought of that ToT  You win more smartness points than me
• Ответить

Bakeku67

@MeEqualsBookWorm no, in the seventh book, the twins and Lee start a radio broadcast called Potterwatch. Maybe we're both just dumb
• Ответить

MeEqualsBookWorm

Yo I haven’t read Potterwatch but you’re not stupid.  That would’ve taken me a minute if I got it at all— unless… am I stupid? ToT
• Ответить

Bakeku67

How do people write like this?!
          I just read one chapter of a story that has multiple, and it felt like I'd just read five chapters of the most agonizing fic, and it was good, well written, not something I would normally ever read, and i will definitely not be reading the rest of it, but omg.
          It was one of the longest chapters, but felt like I must have flipped through at least two extra chapters.
          That is witchcraft beyond my abilities.

Bakeku67

@Hua_Cheng02 yw
• Ответить

Hua_Cheng02

Thanks!
• Ответить

Bakeku67

@Hua_Cheng02 'Misunderstandings' by FatesMistake over on FF
            It's a Snarry
• Ответить