ImaDebaser
HI! I can’t find your comments anymore but you wanted me to watch Hamilton right?? Because I started watching it today!!<3
ImaDebaser
Also I love the ideas of your OC’s and I’m really excited to see how this all turns out!! The names actually match up so so perfectly, ahh!! (Also you’ve sent me on a Hamilton spiral, my family can’t catch a break lmaoooo I loved it so much)
ImaDebaser
Charles Lee - Blackbeard works quite well. He is always talking a big game, and like Lee has retreated. ie begging Whitebeard for his life. (I think Buggy could also work here but)
John Jay - honestly I love my man Kid but I gotta say I don’t think he fits all that well John Jay is more of a background character, not overly aggressive and is quite strategic. I would honestly pick Jinbe. He’s a part of Luffy’s crew, not the forefront but important. (But honestly that’s just my opinion, if he fits for your story, because of the supernova trio, use him!!)
Jefferson - Doflamingo, 1000% yes. Like 10/10 matchup. I agree.
Sally - I think Viola/Violet fits better here because Doflamingo had her trapped working for him, whilst Baby 5 is more family!
Madison - Caesar 100%. Kid wouldn’t fit.
Phillip - Ace. 100%. His death is tragic and it’s as a result of protecting Luffy. Kind of how Phillip dies because Hamilton tells him not to shoot and to aim to the sky.
John Adam’s - Buggy. This really works. He’s a minor annoyance at best. Somehow gains power? I agree.
Maria - I hear ya. I hate Boa soso much. Also though she’s not one to do men’s biddings or have a husband. I think, even though they haven’t really interacted much with Luffy, maybe someone like Perona works. She’s always doing men’s biddings, and also weakens men’s defences and manipulates them.
James Reynolds (Maria’s husband.) - needs to be someone sleasy and abusive. Koby isn’t that. I think if you did Perona as Maria, Absalom would work perfectly.
Kings head - is that a person? I thought it was referring to the fact his head was yoinked;-;
George - honestly I think Akainu fits so perfect. He literally killed Ace and openly mocked Whitebeard, he also was trying to Kill Luffy who Ace died to protect!
Philips friend - I agree. Marco!
ImaDebaser
I’ve done the list, same as yours, most I agree with, I’ve also added my own opinions on some for you to see and decide if you think mine fit or not, so;
Hamilton - Luffy, I agree here obviously.
Burr - Law. I agree again. The tragedy is there! The rivalry with Luffy. Love it.
Laurens - I think Sabo would be best, purely because of his revolutionary ideals and deep bond with Luffy, kind of lines up better. However I get that Ace would fit too for the early death, but technically they do think Sabo is dead so??
Lafayette - Sanji. Honestly the best fit ever. The French, the fighting. Especially with the noble ties for Lafayette and Sanji was born in a well known family.
Mulligan - Zoro. I agree again. He’s loyal, has a wild side, so does Zoro. “making redcoats redder with bloodstains” is also so Zoro core imo!!
King - I think if they don’t work Charlos (the Celestial Dragon from Sabaody) could. I mean he literally tried to claim people as property, whined when he was disrespected, and expected the world to revolve around him.
Washington - Rayleigh. I agree wholeheartedly. Stepped down from piracy like Washington did with presidency. Is a mentor to Luffy, and is respected. I love this choice tbh.
Martha Washington - Agree, Shakky.
Theodosia (love interest) - Robin I agree with. They fit well
Theodosia (child) - personally I’d go with an aged down Baby 5. Because she and Law have more of an intertwined past. They look alike as well.