@littleflower914 It's been a while since I wrote it but if I remember my own book correctly (lol) in the end Hael and Tangie choose different paths in life, Tangie chooses to live on earth and no longer affiliates with the heavens, and while the book doesn't exactly explain what happened to Hael, she chooses to not stay with Mazanin and gives Tangie the choice of doing what she wants. Basically in the end they acknowledge that they're no longer able to walk the same path in life and go their separate ways. Similarly, Hecate and Hela following Tangie tothe village in the end could be interpreted as them also abandoning hell and choosing, like Tangie, to live on earth. The book doesn't say whether they keep contact with Mazanin or whether Tangie meets Hael ever again, but at least where the book left off, Tangie, Hael and Hecate leave their old lives behind, which includes their old acquaintances and friends, and forge a new life/path on their own. But thank you so much for asking and thank you for reading!