OK y'all I need your help. I have two very similar ideas for a story and I need help figuring out which one to do first.
In the first one, Austin is left taking care of his sister Ashley who in the story is 15. They have unexpectedly lost their mom and their dad has never been in their lives. To "cope" with her own grief Ashley begins to rebel against Austin by sneaking out and partying along with underage drinking getting expelled from school for not only getting into fights with other girls but also showing up to school hungover. Fed up with her behavior Austin gives Ashley an ultimatum. She must seek help for her reckless behavior before something bad happens or Austin will have no choice but to cut off all contact with her and kick her out of the house. Seeing how serious he is Ashley decides to finally seek the help she needs or lose the only family she has left.
The other one is the opposite Austin is the rebellious teenager who is sneaking out partying getting into all sorts of trouble getting expelled from school for getting into fights with other boys and showing up to school hungover. Ashley not wanting to give up on her brother gives him an ultimatum of seek help for his behavior of get kicked out of the house and lose the only family he has left. Seeing how serious Ashley is Austin decides to seek out the help he needs before something bad happens.
What scenario do you guys like please help.