quirkstan
@OverseeingNerd142 I have some questions for you: 1. Who is your favourite character from RWBY and why? 2. Whoās your least favourite character from RWBY and why? 3. Whatās your favourite Semblance? 4. Whatās your favourite weapon? 5. How would you have liked Volume 1 to go? Personally, Iād have preferred if the writers confined the plot to Beacon. It gives the audience insight to how Huntsman Academyās, the kind of lessons are taught, and expanding upon Team RWBYās characters. Also, the friction between Ruby and Weiss shouldāve lasted the whole Volume, culminating in the finale when Weiss sees how her attitude is harming the team. Weiss shouldāve also got called out for her behaviour more. 6. How would have liked the White Fang subplot to have been executed. Miles and Luna admitted that they had no idea what they were doing with it and made several mistakes, one of them being how Adamās character was butchered. I could go on, but that would take too much time. Personally, have the Fall of Beacon placed a target on all Faunus on Remnant. Think about it, the White Fang wanted equality. Unfortunately, Adamās little stunt was basically a declaration of war on humanity. All Faunus could have been seen in the same light as the White Fang, giving Faunus discriminators a reason to reinforce their policies. A Civil War Arc could have played out between the Heroes, The White Fang and Salemās Inner Circle, culminating at the end of Volume 5. 7. How would you have liked Nora and Renās characters to have been expanded upon in Volumes 1-3? 8. Whatās your interpretation of a Fully-Realised Maiden? To me, a Fully-Realised Maiden can cast spells rather than just manipulating elements.
quirkstan
2.I donāt think thatās what theyāre trying to do. My guess is that RT was not only showing how Cinder became what she is, but how Atlas is the breeding ground for people like her and Adam. Think about it, Cinder and Adam both lived in Atlas and were oppressed in different ways. Thus, making them what they are today. Why do you think that they were both shown in Volume 6 and the main cast was headed for Atlas? The execution was wrong, but the message is there if you look closely. Cinder and Adam are both victims of the systems that have rise to their rise to villainy. And the source of that is the class system in Atlas.
In my opinion, itās not so much as Cinderās being redeemed. Sheās chosen her path and is clearly sticking to it. The reason her origin was shown is to show how the world can break people. Making them into people that will break it as well. She honestly has a good amount of similarities with Tomura if you think about it.
5. Iām actually doing that in my story. It begins 2 months after Volume 1 as the 1st Semester at Beacon is running. The docks battle wouldnāt have appeared yet. Volume 1 will mostly focus on Izuku learning about Remnant and Aura, with Team RWBYās side plot revolving around their relationship.
6. I actually have a lore drop for how that happened. It started with Adam, but Sienna was the one who pushed it forward. I can explain it for you if youād like me to.
8. No disrespect, but you know Iām taking about the 4 Maidens, right?
OverseeingNerd142
1. I donāt necessarily have a favorite character to be honest sorry to disappoint.
2. I would say my least favorite character would be Cinder at first she seemed like a cool villain now it just seems sheās trying to be redeemable.
3. Glyph is a really great semblance but if Weiss wasnāt so much of a brat to show off maybe she can win any fights with her creations.
4. I would say Crescent Rose makeshift weapons are always interesting to me?
5. I think Volume 1 was just fine as it is but you do have some interesting points to recognize error so I have to agree with you about what you said about Weiss she could have had a personality change to be more likable.
6. Well I think the White Fang were probably at Ken point a group that try to bring Faunus and Humans to come together but turned into an extremist killing group was a bit extreme for me to learn about and your right on the points you made with each of the certain people involved with the White Fang in the first place I would be having second thoughts too.
7. To literally recognize their feelings for each other at some point around Volume 2 since the have been friends since childhood and literally are made for each other?
8. Literally I would say that a Fully Realised Madien is someone who has been evolved from a Huntress to a literally woman of pure concentrated power that should never be taken lightly if trying to over throw them for any circumstance.