Hey! You's probably noticed there's some story inconsistencies when the POV's change. That's on purpose. Jeff is an unreliable narrator. His perspective isn't always how things go, just how he thinks they play out. That's shown in the difference when he catches (Y/N) in the deli/cafe thing with Randy, and now when he interacts with (Y/N) when he's stitching her up. Jeff isn't really sound of mind, so he warps things to git his narrative. He isn't really a good guy here at all.