@joshferna01 Gawr had met Cyrus since the first time Gura met him because they shared the same being. She can see what Gura experiences but not do much. In that she saw Cyrus as nothing, if anything he was a snack. But when she *actually* met him which was on the day of her rampage, she got to see what he's actually like at face value. She saw someone who's no different than any other human but he was someone who overpowered and completely defeated her with his smarts and skills. Gawr, who relied heavily on brute strength and causing fear, couldn't wrap her head around someone like this and so since that day she got "curious".
This curiosity developed over time into something else and through the Atlantis arc she herself realized that she's feeling what Gura is. So you can say that Cyrus had two girls who fell for him.