Hi there, I'm the Fanfiction Critic! I don't write much, but I read – and I mean READ. If you message me I'll almost definitely read your story, a comment guaranteed, a vote most likely. Ask me to fan you and I probably will! I offer reviews and detailed comments – but in messages. Here's how I work...

If you ask me to read and comment on your story, I'll do so. If you ask me to review, I'll privately message you the review as I don't like putting long reviews in comment boxes! Don't feel upset if there's some constructive criticism but most I try to talk mostly about the positive aspects and only touch briefly on the negative aspects.

I do my best to be fair. Also, don't expect me to criticise how much you know about the celebrity/book characters/game characters/movie characters etc. you are writing about. I review the writing, not the cast! I like to read One Direction fanfictions especially but I will review other ones as well.

I'm not some book review goddess, and I'm not perfect, so not everyone will agree with the things I say in my reviews. But to make sure that at least a few people agree with me, I'll ask some other people to read your story as well, and ask for their opinion on it. I'll take other people's opinions into account when writing my reviews.

I hope I get to read your story soon! Message me and I'll reply! Remember, ask me to read, comment vote, and fan, and I will most likely do all four, definitely the first two. Thanks, and bye!
  • JoinedOctober 10, 2012


Last Message
The_Fanfic_Critic The_Fanfic_Critic Nov 10, 2012 02:02AM
@CeannaJay Sure. Will do!
View all Conversations

1 Reading List