Jake Peralta:
"Alright, number one. Please sing the opening to 'I Want It That Way.'"

Suspect #1:
🎶 "You are... my fire..." 🎶

Jake:
"Okay, number two, keep it going."

Suspect #2:
🎶 "The one... desire..." 🎶

Jake:
"Nice. Number three?"

Suspect #3:
🎶 "Believe... when I say..." 🎶

Jake (singing along softly):
🎶 "I want it that way..." 🎶
"Number four?"

Suspect #4:
🎶 "But we... are two worlds apart..." 🎶

Jake (completely into it):
🎶 "I never wanna hear you say..." 🎶
"Number five."

Suspect #5:
🎶 "I want it that way." 🎶

Witness (suddenly gasps):
"Oh my God... it's number five.
Number five killed my brother."

Jake (pauses, guilty):
"...Oh my God.
I forgot about that part."