WeekendReader
@JennaMark Sin & Ruin (Kindle Release) So S&R released on Kindle this morning -- and I only saw Book 1 in my library. (I pre-ordered both.) Because I'm the kind of person that ruins surprises for myself -- I jumped straight to the last chapter to see where it ends in the saga. Well...It ends RIGHT AFTER Selene catches Alaric cheating w/ her ex-friend (and father's mistress). So -- that means that we probably read most of the story of Book 2, already, too -- minus Selene deciding to come back to Alaric. It's only a duet -- and nothing has happened in Book 1, basically. So -- we've read probably 75% of Book 2, my guess. BUT -- I write to you this morning to pass on 2 things in particular: 1) I now see that Book 2 won't even release until 8/28. So -- it's going to be a slow release - dragged out, unfortunately. 2) As for Book 1 -- You're going to be annoyed, Nancy - because there was (clearly) ZERO proof reading. ZERO. Just my skim of the very last Chp of Book 1 had a fragment -- missing the substance of the sentence -- that would have been impossible to miss if anyone proofed it. So, too, does it use wrong verbs -- the one I caught wrote that Selene "loves to the door" instead of "moves." And, for clarity, these were caught by me in a SUPER-FAST skim read -- where 9x out of 10 I won't catch typos (because our brains provide correction subconsciously). Our brains can't fix what doesn't make sense, though, and these typos were so bad that I had to pause and re-read up and down to orient to what was missing HAD the sentence been finished -- or meant (if I corrected verbs). NOBODY would miss these types of typos if they just bothered to proof -- bearing in mind it is (also) the LAST chapter of the book! So, God knows what the middle of this book is going to look like. Anyway - I thought of you immediately -- and thought, "Oh, Nancy is going to just hate this." So -- head's up.
JennaMark
@WeekendReader SIN & RUIN & A LAUGH Oh, I laughed so hard. Because I just downloaded S&R an hour ago and *immediately* went to the end to see where this book ends!! We are the same!! So your message completely cracked me up! So, I only skimmed the last chapter or so, and I did see some typos. I saw stuff that seemed different, in a worse way. I saw some stuff I cringed at (described prior violence… which I can just skim through). So, the typos throughout sound awful and so unnecessary!! Get a proofreader. Get an ARC team! I can’t believe some of the quirks and characteristics that made Alaric so interesting have been changed. What a HUGE disappointment! Speaking of disappointment, part 2 not available until the end of August?! What the heck?? And if this book only covered to the cheating… there is A LOT to cover in book 2. Did you check that list of triggers for book 2? That seems like a lot. So, book 1 was barely a teaser and everything happens in book 2. I’m just speechless. After the wait, I thought we were getting A book, not a two-parter. And why are there so many typos in material that was already published? Plus, we’ve been told she’s a published author… why the poor quality? I’m just overall so disappointed. I’ll be interested in seeing what the reviews on Amazon and GoodReads say. I’ll probably still read it but I’m not sure whether I’ll start this weekend. Nudge me if you want me to read faster.
•
Reply
WeekendReader
@jennamark - More on Sin & Ruin So - I skimmed the whole thing since I've read the book. Typos are throughout -- half finished sentences - sentences without verbs - no periods at the end of sentences, and - (twice) I found complete sections that shifted from 1st person to third person neutral narrator, etc. This was 100% not proofread. Anyway - there's no violence in this book. That's saved for the next one. But - they changed Alaric - he's no longer (from what I can see) written as being on the spectrum - I can't find the conversation w/ Cassian that described characteristics showing him struggle with emotion - they (I think) removed the first lunch of Selene's at Alaric's family where his brother and Derrick stop mid-bite realizing Alaric is falling for Selene. They also removed 1 massive chapter of Alaric's internal POV on the cheating - what he thinks is love - which he describes - and why he doesn't think he loves Selene (even though we see what he describes is what he is actually doing). Their first meeting at the restaurant feels, now, far more transactional - him just a sketchy Alpha mafia guy - immediately telling her how gorgeous she is before she even sits - while the old version was slow, restrained, with a long silence,and him saying he's surprised, w/ Selene showing insecurity, and then him saying she's beautiful. Now, he just sounds like every guy you meet in a bar. He is much more pronounced about "wife-expectation" - even in the first meeting - which was not in the first book. He is described as possessive with everything - so when the book speaks to him always holding her, it no longer comes across as anything but Alaric being possessive because it's who HE is as opposed to because of who SHE is to HIM. The book has lost its soul - and was published in a hurry, for certain. Considering how much territory has to be covered in Book 2 - unless it's DOUBLE the length of Book 1 - it's going to read like Cliff Notes. Just my $.02.
•
Reply