Xylem3Keys

Writing about Sodor Volcano/Earthquake or any forced war AUs be like - Didn't do Research Award

SuePodgorski

@SayThatAgainIDareYou Yeah, like HOW????? Volcano's do not turn into monsters. And then at the end more characters are turned into monsters(the ony ones I remember are Gordon and Henry) Again, HOW, it is not possable to be turned into monsters from volcanoes. And I'm pretty sure Gordon and a few other monsters were derailed when they died. SO HOW DID THEY GET UPRIGHT. And then the battle just turns into a copy and paste SLFD battle.
• Reply

SayThatAgainIDareYou

this message may be offensive 
@SuePodgorski The worst part about that volcano au is nothing even REMOTELY FUCKING EXPLAINS what caused Arthur to become beast like what happened? nothing even remotely hints at how he became a monster
• Reply

Xylem3Keys

this message may be offensive 
@IsleofPigsStudios Hell. Did they forget that Germany was split into two from the US and Soviet Union in 1945?? It's laughable how people find this to be "good" when it's completely dogshit. Don't forget about Cold War. It's not technically like WW2 and this shit is so stupid like there was no disaster or invasion on the UK when it has the most powerful military ever.
          	  
          	  And by the way, Bowler had made a very well written document about how to WW2 TTTE in the most accurate and realistic way possible. Worth the read. I'm no fan of wars shoved in TTTE but he wrote much better than other horse shit war AUs.
          	  https://docs.google.com/document/d/1CSCCUqec9vY4R_oUe8bsyqtZJsgjcjUrJQCxkoW89yA/edit?usp=drivesdk
• Reply

SuePodgorski

Instead of rereading brainrot like TSCW, I finally got around to reading your au I really love it, it's really good, I've ony read the first chapter I'll read chapter 2 later, but I enjoyed chapter 1, keep it up.
          
          If there's 1 thing I have to comment I don't like, I think the "2 years later" could be a bit more spaced out and in a place where it kind of stands out more. But beside that I'm enjoying.
          
          Although I also got a question, why isn't Fergus in the au, or is it because of his basis and how low powered it is.

SuePodgorski

@Xylem3Keys Well that's good.
• Reply

Xylem3Keys

@SuePodgorski actually, I take that back. I'm adding Fergus but he won't appear as a bg character or a supporting character
• Reply

SuePodgorski

@Xylem3Keys I did enjoy it, and hopefully you get motivation back soon.
• Reply

Xylem3Keys

Writing about Sodor Volcano/Earthquake or any forced war AUs be like - Didn't do Research Award

SuePodgorski

@SayThatAgainIDareYou Yeah, like HOW????? Volcano's do not turn into monsters. And then at the end more characters are turned into monsters(the ony ones I remember are Gordon and Henry) Again, HOW, it is not possable to be turned into monsters from volcanoes. And I'm pretty sure Gordon and a few other monsters were derailed when they died. SO HOW DID THEY GET UPRIGHT. And then the battle just turns into a copy and paste SLFD battle.
• Reply

SayThatAgainIDareYou

this message may be offensive 
@SuePodgorski The worst part about that volcano au is nothing even REMOTELY FUCKING EXPLAINS what caused Arthur to become beast like what happened? nothing even remotely hints at how he became a monster
• Reply

Xylem3Keys

this message may be offensive 
@IsleofPigsStudios Hell. Did they forget that Germany was split into two from the US and Soviet Union in 1945?? It's laughable how people find this to be "good" when it's completely dogshit. Don't forget about Cold War. It's not technically like WW2 and this shit is so stupid like there was no disaster or invasion on the UK when it has the most powerful military ever.
            
            And by the way, Bowler had made a very well written document about how to WW2 TTTE in the most accurate and realistic way possible. Worth the read. I'm no fan of wars shoved in TTTE but he wrote much better than other horse shit war AUs.
            https://docs.google.com/document/d/1CSCCUqec9vY4R_oUe8bsyqtZJsgjcjUrJQCxkoW89yA/edit?usp=drivesdk
• Reply

Xylem3Keys

I will not make a playlist video. Even if I do, don't expect FNAF, cinematic, metal rock music or any copyrighted music shoved into my AU.
          
          Okay I'm gonna say this, I have listened to metal for over a decade. I've listened to FNAF music less often but still quite enjoyed them. But for my AU, the metal rock, or electronic remix genre will not be associated with From Sea to Beyond Confine. It has a dark haunting atmospheric tone with the depressing mood. It will all be on Newgrounds with no copyrighted music (if I make an animation). And yes Newgrounds there prohibits copyright music or reposted music.
          
          In my opinion, I find playlist videos to be very boring and unoriginal. Like there is a playlist feature you can make it and add songs you look up on YouTube and put it on your channel which is faster than just a video with still images of a background and an engine. I also don't belive that FNAF and metal fits into the Thomas universe (horror or not).
          
          Feel free to disagree or block me if you can't handle my opinion! <3

Xylem3Keys

this message may be offensive 
I'm going to be very truthful and honest about the early years when Sodor AUs were a thing. Time to speak up about it and maybe get demonized for telling the truth lmao.
          
          Admittedly I didn't liked them in the first place back in the early 2020s. I was sticking with Sodor Fallout this entire time (while avoiding content farm Elsagate 2.0 slop like role swaps and dog shit slide shows and edits. Also if I you make that type of shit please stay far the fuck away from me)
          
          Because I shit you not when watching these ripoffs such as Sodor Mist, Sodor Decay and reading the old Sodor Leakage. I lost every single fucking braincell I had when I always hear the runaway theme playing in the background at the beginning of the disaster EVERY FUCKING TIME. It's so FUCKING UNORIGINAL and I was thinking so hard in my head that I just wanted to say it out loud (but didn't because of course I would be berated by fucking kids telling me to kms and couldn't up with a better argument). Get a reevaluation. TheRingGuy's deleted all of his stories (except LDF) because they all suck dick.
          
          Also about shoving war story into TTTE: It's going to suck dick if you couldn't do any research or make actual storytelling (yeah yk bombing of sodor, Molly and the Germans attack or any other war aus are objectively garbage). If you're going to keep it that way with the copy and paste SF formula, expect being the ripped the fuck into.
          
          Oh if you can't handle constructive criticism then boo fucking hoo sucks to suck. Maybe don't make an account or an au. It's mind boggling how these unoriginal slop content get thousands of views on YouTube than AU stories with really good writing and storytelling.
          
          Now with that end of rant, I'll tell you about chapter 3 of From Sea to Beyond Confine: In progress still. Writer's block sucks but I can show you one only reveal: Emily finds Noel and Warren on the line.

Xylem3Keys

this message may be offensive 
@IsleofPigsStudios goofy edgy aaaaaahhhh trains summoning guns type sci-fi shit omg I hate it. I hate it sm
• Reply

IsleofPigsStudios

this message may be offensive 
@Xylem3Keys Not to mention, like I said, HOW IS THOMAS ABLE TO RUN WITH THOSE GUNS? Two of them are in his TANKS! And the third is in his CAB! It’d be a miracle if they even GOT Thomas to move so far so fast with so little water, and with so little room for a crew. This just SCREAMS “IDGAF about logic, I’m throwing shit at the wall to see what sticks”
• Reply

Xylem3Keys

this message may be offensive 
@IsleofPigsStudios Dark Realms sucks so much piss like how the fuck can fat hatt in white suit can control a tiny ass island when it's connected right next to the UK? I really hate the gun shit shoved into edge lord Sodor AUs when you know, owning a gun there is a privilege. Not a right. It's not the United States for fucks sake (yes I looked that up).
            
            Decay Edward and Henry are just SF beast but more shit with those ahhh oval eyes it's not that scary.
            
            No need to apologize. I don't blame you for leaving the AU community. Writer's block really does suck. When I get done with From Sea to Beyond Confine, I have plans for making a prequel (not sequel) it takes place outside of Sodor with new characters. I've been watching Zombie films on Netflix (Train to Busan is the goat) and another called Seoul Station only Tubi, I needed to watch more to get inspired to write this fanfic.
• Reply

SayThatAgainIDareYou

Question about from sea to beyond confine:
          Why are adaptaitions banned? i can see why a lot of other stuff is banned but I don't really get why adaptations are banned (If my English is bad it's cuz im an Argentine sorry if that distracts you)

Xylem3Keys

@SayThatAgainIDareYou Reasons
            - This is a vent project where I cope with my IRL personal issues.
            - I don't want to end up like the old AUs such as Mist, Decay, Fallout, Eclipse, LFD, and more.
            - I don't want it to be popular in the TTTE community in general, especially where hardcore Sodor Fallout ripoff fanboys would come to me demanding a chapter or a sequel (which is why I'm not posting the story here). My AU would be completely vandalized as they would do anything to "fix," "rewrite," and completely vandalized my story and overstepping my boundaries.
• Reply

Xylem3Keys

Beware of p/rn bots guys. They're roaming around on this platform but thankfully I reported one to the staff and they banned one. Hope they continue doing this.

IsleofPigsStudios

@Xylem3Keys I block those bots as soon as I see them.
• Reply

SuePodgorski

@Xylem3Keys I didn't even know about know about Instagram, Facebook and Tiktok doing it mainly because I barely pay attention to them outside of Tiktok nearly being banned a few times. I'm sure Deviantart would also have that problem based on awful or weird artwork I've seen come out of there, but that's just a thought.
• Reply

Xylem3Keys

@SuePodgorski and Instagram, and Facebook, and TikTok, and YouTube. All were incompetent pos.
• Reply

Xylem3Keys

From Sea to Beyond Confine announcement
          Chapter 2 has been released: https://archiveofourown.org/works/68289101/chapters/180761256#workskin
          Update: Removed all the time events + fixed punctuation grammars

IsleofPigsStudios

@Xylem3Keys Removed, sorry it took a bit. I was on a walk
• Reply

Xylem3Keys

this message may be offensive 
@IsleofPigsStudios Okay update: Remove necroworms from Pretty Blood please. In trivia list where you wrote what my story is inspired by and replace it with Train to Busan. Holy shit I can't believe I used to look up Little Cute Corpse/Little Deadly Thing.
• Reply

Xylem3Keys

@IsleofPigsStudios I'm okay with that
• Reply

Xylem3Keys

From Sea to Beyond Confine announcement
          Chapter 1 has been release. I wanted to start off something unique at the opening of the chapter that is way more different than most Sodor AUs. I'm also new to posting there as well.
          
          https://archiveofourown.org/works/68289101/chapters/176697501

Xylem3Keys

@Xylem3Keys Update: Adding the part where his parents gave him a necklace
• Reply

SuePodgorski

@Xylem3Keys Understanable, have fun on there.
• Reply

Xylem3Keys

@SuePodgorski AO3 has more features and more organized when it comes to tags and labled your stories to mature audiences when you edit your stories. It's non-profitable unlike Wattpad.
• Reply