YouCanCallMeCorn

As an experiment, I asked AI to revise a paragraph from my writing. I was curious to see what enhancements other writers might achieve by using AI. 
          	
          	My paragraph:
          	
          	One would have immediately thought that he at least had a deep, intimidating voice. What he has, though, is of a boy who has yet to stop drinking his mother's milk.
          	
          	AI's:
          	
          	One might expect him to possess a deep, commanding voice, but instead, he speaks with the high-pitched timbre of a boy who has yet to outgrow his mother's embrace.
          	
          	Perhaps the AI has better flow and grammar. But it has erased my tone. My voice as a writer. It removed my humour. 
          	
          	So again, I don't understand why use AI to write your book. It's boring 

YouCanCallMeCorn

@mindofmals Thank you. I got curious because a reader confessed that they had used AI to know the ending :D
Reply

YouCanCallMeCorn

@SeraDrake Can’t they see that they all start to sound the same? Whatever happened to the beauty of a unique voice? They’re so afraid of making mistakes and learning from them that they’re missing the chance to truly grow and improve
Reply

mindofmals

@YouCanCallMeCorn your paragraph is way better than the AI one, the AI one sounds so robotic
Reply

YouCanCallMeCorn

As an experiment, I asked AI to revise a paragraph from my writing. I was curious to see what enhancements other writers might achieve by using AI. 
          
          My paragraph:
          
          One would have immediately thought that he at least had a deep, intimidating voice. What he has, though, is of a boy who has yet to stop drinking his mother's milk.
          
          AI's:
          
          One might expect him to possess a deep, commanding voice, but instead, he speaks with the high-pitched timbre of a boy who has yet to outgrow his mother's embrace.
          
          Perhaps the AI has better flow and grammar. But it has erased my tone. My voice as a writer. It removed my humour. 
          
          So again, I don't understand why use AI to write your book. It's boring 

YouCanCallMeCorn

@mindofmals Thank you. I got curious because a reader confessed that they had used AI to know the ending :D
Reply

YouCanCallMeCorn

@SeraDrake Can’t they see that they all start to sound the same? Whatever happened to the beauty of a unique voice? They’re so afraid of making mistakes and learning from them that they’re missing the chance to truly grow and improve
Reply

mindofmals

@YouCanCallMeCorn your paragraph is way better than the AI one, the AI one sounds so robotic
Reply

YouCanCallMeCorn

I don't understand how I'm already familiar with my writing style, can recognize my weaknesses, and know how to strengthen my prose, and yet I still can't figure out how to improve my first chapter. Is this just a normal writer struggle, or is my brain being lazy?
          
          

katiegoesmew

@YouCanCallMeCorn I put a note in my files to reread it when I get back around to your story
Reply

YouCanCallMeCorn

@Olivia_Benedetti Glad I'm not the only one then
Reply

YouCanCallMeCorn

@katiegoesmew Took me long but I've finally revised it. But I know it still could be better. I just don't know how. I did what I could
Reply

YouCanCallMeCorn

My app glitched and showed me I was following profiles I had never seen before. It even multiplied several accounts. I spent 30 minutes unfollowing. So if I accidentally unfollowed you, let me know 

Olivia_Benedetti

@YouCanCallMeCorn yeah I can’t write either on here like the charters I write on it cuts off 
Reply

YouCanCallMeCorn

@Olivia_Benedetti  Wattpad keeps doing st*pid things. It centralises the last paragraph every time I edit a chapter. Sometimes it italicises sentences that don't need to be italicised. With all the money it makes, I  was expecting a high quality app but ao3 is still much better
Reply

Olivia_Benedetti

That’s weird glitch < 3 
Reply

YouCanCallMeCorn

Was looking for a review shop that is still open. Found one. Skimmed their reviews and they were obviously written by AI
          
          Come on

YouCanCallMeCorn

@Olivia_Benedetti Honestly, I'd rather have less than 500 words of a review written by a human than a "review" written by a bot.
Reply

YouCanCallMeCorn

@SeraDrake  You make a good point. It’s especially noticeable when the shop owner isn’t fluent in English, yet their reviews are free of grammar mistakes. Another red flag is when they can’t even mention the title of the book or the characters. It all comes off as so generic.
Reply

Olivia_Benedetti

I agree. My reviews take me 1-2 days to  do it depends how  many chapters and how long the chapters are + how many words and how much I need to talk about ahah 
Reply

YouCanCallMeCorn

          I recently exchanged books with other authors on a Discord channel. While I received some positive feedback, one "reviewer" mentioned she struggled with certain chapters. Curious, I asked her why, so I could work on improving them. She said, "Some of your chapters have minimal dialogue."
          
          Apparently, many readers tend to skip descriptions and focus solely on dialogue to understand (yeah right) the story. Some only read the descriptions if there are spicy scenes (ugh)
          
          
          Everyone went quiet. And I guess she felt how the atmosphere suddenly shifted as she tried to change the topic.
          
          What is happening? This is so sad 
          
          

SeraDrake

@YouCanCallMeCorn - Now everybody's reading Colleen Hoover. She's much more smartphone-brain-friendly than GRRM ever was.
            
            GRRM wrote ASOIAF long before TikTok became a thing, though. Hell, he wrote most of ASOIAF before people started using smartphones. A Game of Thrones: 1996. a Clash of Kings: 1998. A Storm of Swords: 2000. A Feast for Crows: 2004. A Dance with Dragons: 2011.
            
            Smartphones and TikTok have ruined everything.
Reply

YouCanCallMeCorn

@SeraDrakeI really need George R.R. Martin to publish the final books in the A Song of Ice and Fire series. When Game of Thrones premiered, it seemed like everyone and their mother was diving into the books, which are known for their dense prose. Sure, we could debate that some people were only reading to be part of the hype, but at least they were reading!
Reply

SeraDrake

@YouCanCallMeCorn - Smartphone brain. Some people who spend all their time scrolling through messages and then scroll some more to an app to read books online - on the smartphone - can't concentrate on challenging prose, especially not when it's couched in long paragraphs full of complex sentences that require close attention. 
            
            The long paragraphs hurt eyes that are already strained by staring at a small glowing screen for too long. The complexity is hard to focus on. 
            
            It's easier to just look at snappy dialogue, stuff that is written in an easy-to-comprehend, colloquial style and only uses one or two sentences at a time. 
            
            For the prose descriptions, if they must be there at all, it's preferred to have them contain easy-to-recognize tropes and situations, things that don't have to be focused on too closely, things the reader understands as memes and concepts without having to really read. 
            
            Literature is easier when predigested that way.
            
            I can't say I'm happy about this development.
Reply

YouCanCallMeCorn

I was barely 18 or 19 when I started writing TK. It’s frustrating how much has happened since then, causing multiple delays, but looking back, I’m grateful. By the time the darker themes emerged in my writing, I was older and wiser. I’ve always been sensitive to heavy topics, but now I understand them on a deeper level—and that makes a difference. Knowing a subject isn’t enough to write about it; you have to respect it.  
          
          I’m glad I gave myself the time and space to step back when I needed to.

YouCanCallMeCorn

I'm now writing a new chapter, and I love it when all the hints I've spread come together. This is why I love writing notes

katiegoesmew

@YouCanCallMeCorn See, I'm the odd combination of pantser and perfectionist. I'm learning the story as much as the reader is, because I'm making it up as I go. But the further I get into it, the more I plan, and I'm a person who hates plot holes and inconsistencies, so I have all the loose threads in mind, and I'm looking for ways to tie them up. When I got back around for editing, that's when I have a plan, and I smooth everything out there.
Reply

YouCanCallMeCorn

@katiegoesmew I can't do the "Just write and see where it goes" approach. Now, if only I wasn't a perfectionist...
Reply

YouCanCallMeCorn

We were all having a fine discussion until they got to my fic. They debated whether it was a romantasy or a fantasy romance story. Personally, I believe it's the latter because it focuses more on the protagonist's goal. In fact, so much so, that his journeys and the people affected by his decision are more highlighted than the protagonist (which is the point!). Calling it a romantasy would imply that it has heavy romance in it when I rarely include a romantic scene. Then again, I'm the author. Maybe the readers see it differently. 

YouCanCallMeCorn

@katiegoesmew  Thank you. I was wondering too, but then again, the MC's love for his brother is much stronger than any romantic feelings he has for anyone. He can and he will kill them for his brother if he has to. So it cannot be called romantasy 
Reply

katiegoesmew

@YouCanCallMeCorn I would agree with you. For it to be a romantasy, I would say both fantasy and romance elements would have to be so strong, it would be hard to choose one genre as primary over the other. But your book is definitely weighted much more toward fantasy than romance.
Reply

YouCanCallMeCorn

My heart hurts so much. A Discord reader revealed to me that they fed my fic to an AI bot so they could see its conclusion. She felt bad because the new chapter was nothing like the AI's. 
          
          My own reader did this to me. I feel deeply betrayed. I try to avoid AI, yet this happened to me. I understand that waiting is difficult, but there is no reason to do so. Writing has become difficult for me because I am still in therapy after getting out of the war zone. I get chronic pains now and again. I'm an amputee, for goodness' sake.
          
          It's selfishness. My heart hurts, yet I am not crying. I'm not sure what's happening to me. I can't remember the last time I cried. It's as if my body is refusing to. I'm actually much more angry and disappointed.

katiegoesmew

@YouCanCallMeCorn Unfortunately, all true. All those times I got bored when I was a kid because I didn't have constant access to a computer, or phone, or tablet, or whatever? Those were the times I had to get creative and make things to do. Like tell stories when playing with dolls, or go to the library and read, or start writing some of those stories down. People need more boredom in their lives so they can figure out how to use their brains again.
Reply

YouCanCallMeCorn

@katiegoesmew  I can’t bring myself to forgive her. At least, not yet. She was shocked that the new chapter was nothing like the AI's version, and I couldn’t help but think, What did you expect?
            
            People hate hearing it, but media literacy really is dying. Just look around: students relying on ChatGPT to write their essays, or Netflix recently decided to spoon-feed audiences by making characters narrate their thoughts and feelings so the story is easier to digest.
            
            It’s all about quick consumption now. Originality is fading, and everyone’s starting to sound the same. What’s worse is that most people don’t even care as long as it sounds “smart.”
            
Reply

katiegoesmew

@YouCanCallMeCorn That's...I didn't even know that was a thing. How can an AI bot predict a story's ending? I really, really hate AI.
            
            I had someone message me on another platform saying they liked my story, but they didn't have time to read it, so they wanted me to tell them the details of it. I was like, um, I wrote it for a reason, so you just have to read it. And then they were asking if I had it up on social media in an audio form so they could listen to it...I ended up blocking them, because even though they didn't have time to read my story, they apparently had time to keep harassing me about alternate ways for them to get the content? Idk. It was weird.
            
            Yes, it's very selfish, and it's very lazy. And what you're feeling is valid.  It's easy to say "don't let it get you down," but not so easy to put into practice. You're putting your heart and soul into writing, and there are people who don't value that, but it is valuable, and so are you. So, do what you need to do to take care of yourself, and just know that the people who settle for AI are settling for cheap imitations of a truly beautiful work of art. And that's their problem, not yours. *hugs*
Reply