im gonna clarify a little more; in these type of situations with SA, you always believe the victim until further proof. but at the end of the day we don't know these people personally; we only see what they show us. we all know melanie could be a completely different person, and i know we don't want to believe it, but it's the truth. same with timothy. we know it has been "proven" she has "lied", but has it really happened? we don't know what went down that night and we never will. so to end it off, i am not on anybodys side. melanie needs to speak out about this situation. she's losing tons and tons of followers because she isn't speaking about it a lot. we need her side of the story. i know a lot of people, and you guys, love melanie but there's just so much going on. melanie needs to talk about it.