Professor: "Imagine you're standing beside a railway switch. A runaway trolley is heading toward five people tied to the tracks. If you pull the lever, it will divert to another track, where one person is tied down instead. If you do nothing, the five will die. What would you do?"
Student 1: "I'd pull the lever, Professor."
Professor: "Why?"
Student 1: "Because saving five lives is better than saving one."
Professor: "I see. Anyone with a different view?"
Student 2: "I wouldn't pull the lever."
Professor: "Why not?"
Student 2: "Because if I do, I'll be the one who causes that person's death. If I don't touch the lever, I won't be choosing who lives or dies."
Professor: "Fair point."
He looked toward the back of the room.
Professor: "Miss Asahi?"
Asahi: "Professor, may I ask something before I answer?"
Professor: "Go ahead."
Asahi: "Professor, if the purpose of this exercise is to determine which life is more valuable, then any answer I give would already accept a premise I have yet to examine. Before deciding, I would first ask whether these are truly the only choices... and who created the dilemma in the first place."
Professor: "For the purpose of this exercise, assume those are the only two choices."
Asahi: "Then my answer would be incomplete, Professor. Whatever choice I make would answer the dilemma, but not the question that matters most."
Will You Stand by Me, Attorney?
https://www.wattpad.com/story/413277453